Files
MeanField/experiments/REDUCED_SURFACE_STUDY_2026-09-18.md

3.6 KiB
Raw Blame History

One-hour reduced smooth surface study — 2026-09-18

Authorized wall-clock window: 19:30:15–20:30:15 UTC. Branch: research/reduced-smooth-surface-20260918, parent 6ceda61.

Keep Q3 displacement/surface, Q4 reference geometry, Q2 DG density/potential, Q3 enthalpy and RT2 gravity. No central-density constraint. n=1.5,J=0. No production API, operator or extension change. Single MPI rank.

Frozen affine embedding q=q0+B a. The base q0 is never projected. Construct real spherical harmonics through degree L at actual surface radial nodes; orthonormalize the Q3 interpolants using q14 prepared physical surface area. Thin QR of S B and R^-1 B supplies separate normalized state and dual test maps. Solve Qf^T Jnormalized Qx p=-Qf^T Fnormalized. The projected full inverse Qx^T Mnormalized^-1 Qf is an approximation, not an exact reduced inverse. All other unknowns/equations remain active. Cold FGMRES, eta=.03, max200, restart160, same gravity-Schur preconditioner (one sweep, relaxation.5).

Priority: fresh full-space direction at the prior Q3 six-update endpoint, then L4 there, then L2 and L8 (L6 optional); analytic-seed L4 only if time permits. Stop launching FEM cases by20:20; reserve remaining time for independent artifact audit and reporting. No convergence claim from frozen steps. Cases, builds, and full numerical audits run serially. A library-only Q3 warm rebuild may overlap editing experiment-only headers; no production source changes.

Raw independent trial alphas 1,1/4,1/16,1/1024. Preserve original and reduced residuals, separate linear gates, full/reduced slopes, excluded shape forces, and exact restoration checks. Observational merit criterion is norm(Ftrial)<=(1-1e-4 alpha)*norm(Fbase), evaluated separately in both spaces. No trial accepted, no SOC, no positivity repair. q14/q18 physical measurements at base and the first/largest prepared trial only; all trial residuals saved. Direction physical observer q10/q14 reused from the preceding audited study.

Acceptance of an observation requires algebra/transpose/full-rank control tests, true reduced gate classification, finite vectors, source/input/output hashes, and exact saved-state restoration. Reduced success is not full success. Virial1e-5, interior physical errors, density sign, and omitted force remain separate measurements. No selected norm reduction can certify a physical root.

Implementation

Experiment-only headers:

  • reduced_surface_basis.hpp: scalar radial-amplitude FE trace basis and quadrature-defined physical surface mass metric, explicit rank/orthogonality checks, and raw data for independent verification.
  • reduced_surface_operators.hpp: two separate QR maps, reduced operator, projected flexible preconditioner and deterministic algebra checks.
  • reduced_surface_diagnostics.hpp: frozen solve, both original/reduced gates, excluded-force decomposition, raw trials and restoration invariants.
  • audit_reduced_surface.py: independent artifact algebra and corruption tests.

The diagnostic executable adds experiment-only flags --reduced-surface-probe and --surface-degree (0 means full-space control); no production-facing API is modified. Degrees are runtime experimental choices while operator/inverse compatibility and the inherited preconditioner application contract remain compile-time constrained. Actual mesh dimensions and normalization factors are necessarily checked at runtime. Existing physical observers are reused.

Evidence root: ../../diagnostics/reduced_surface_2026-09-18 relative to this checkout. The preceding study remains on its two committed research branches.

Results

Pending the bounded serial campaign and its independent artifact audit.