Files
MeanField/experiments/KRYLOV_WINDOW_HYPOTHESIS_2026-09-16.md

2.0 KiB

Larger Krylov window

This branch changes only the sandbox example's existing FGMRES restart setting from 40 to 160. It adds no public API and does not change the general backend default. The warm-start safeguard is a separate hypothesis and branch.

Matched evidence

The common diagnostic executable at commit 9bd4af6 ran n=1, K=2/pi, M=1, J=0.05, with no central-density constraint, on the unchanged sandbox.smesh. Both runs used nonlinear rtol=1e-8, atol=0, linear tolerance=0.03, and at most 200 linear iterations. Only the restart window differed.

Result Restart 40 Restart 160
Accepted full Newton steps 5 7
Final normalized residual 6.03609e-9 3.38036e-11
Strict convergence No: sixth linear solve fails Yes
Total linear iterations, including failed attempt 370 292
Largest final virial error among four definitions, q=14/18 3.73183e-7 3.73466e-7

The first four steps coincide exactly. The larger window first changes the fifth linear solve. This is live nonlinear evidence, supplemented by the earlier frozen-system comparisons. Single wall-time samples (291 versus 272 seconds, including physical diagnostics) do not establish a general speedup.

Limits and validation

The larger window requires more Krylov storage. It is a useful example setting, not a universal default: n=1.5 without the central constraint still stalls with this window, and eventually fails a linear gate. The n=3 frozen control also needs a stronger numerical treatment. This change does not establish a fraction of critical rotation and does not alter the convergence or virial tolerances.

Removing the n=1 example's central-density constraint is independently supported on research/central-constraint-20260916; combine the two changes for the intended example. Compilation and a nonrotating run of the combined example are pending. Raw results and exact build/mesh/executable provenance are retained in the workspace's diagnostics/numerical_campaign_2026-09-16/controls directory.