\documentclass[11pt,a4paper]{article} \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} \usepackage[utf8]{inputenc} \usepackage{lmodern} \usepackage[margin=23mm]{geometry} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb} \usepackage{booktabs,longtable,array} \usepackage{graphicx} \usepackage{xcolor} \usepackage{xurl} \usepackage{microtype} \usepackage{enumitem} \usepackage{hyperref} \hypersetup{colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue!45!black,urlcolor=blue!55!black, pdftitle={MeanField numerical research and consolidation handoff}, pdfauthor={MeanField research record}} \setlength{\emergencystretch}{3em} \setlength{\parskip}{0.35em} \setlength{\parindent}{0pt} \setcounter{tocdepth}{2} \setcounter{secnumdepth}{3} \setlist{itemsep=0.25em,topsep=0.35em} \title{MeanField numerical research\\and consolidation handoff\\ \large Formulation, experiments, evidence, architecture, and remaining work} \author{Research record prepared with Codex\\ \small Source and numerical evidence: 16--20 September 2026} \date{20 September 2026} \begin{document} \maketitle \thispagestyle{empty} \vfill \begin{center} Experimental three-dimensional FEM stellar equilibria\\ Independent density; coupled free surface; polytropic EOS\\[1em] \textbf{The moderately rotating $n=3$ and full virial targets remain open.}\\[1em] This document separates measured results from hypotheses, and retained research tools from promoted defaults. \end{center} \clearpage \tableofcontents \clearpage \section{Purpose, scope and current conclusion} MeanField is an experimental three-dimensional finite-element laboratory for steady rotating stellar equilibria. Its immediate purpose is to establish reliable numerical choices for a later implementation, rather than to present a finished stellar-evolution or production equilibrium code. The user is independently rewriting the implementation in order to own and understand the eventual shipped software. The useful output of this investigation is therefore the formulation, verified contracts, measured successes and failures, and reproducible evidence that can guide that rewrite. This report consolidates the work recorded from 16 through 19 September 2026 and the source/evidence integration performed on 20 September. Earlier optimization and validation records are preserved as historical sources. The conversation is not treated as an experimental log: quantitative claims below come from committed reports, campaign manifests, saved vectors, diagnostic tables and recorded checks. The initial approximately tenfold performance gain and approximately 20-second Newton step for the nonrotating $n=1$ model were the user's starting observation. They are not remeasured as a new speedup in this consolidation. At the outset, limited testing suggested plausible $n=1$ models at very low rotation, described by the user as roughly 1.5 percent of critical, while increasing index or rotation produced residual plateaus. That rough starting description is not a calibrated critical-rotation measurement for the later campaign inputs. \subsection{Physical and software objectives} The immediate physical target is a moderately rotating $n=3$ polytrope, with an eventual comparison against ESTER. The operational rotation goal is at least 50 percent of critical rotation. The more distant ambition of exceeding 99 percent of critical rotation is outside the demonstrated regime and would require renewed attention to surface regularity and the vanishing effective gravity near mass shedding. No value of the dimensionless angular momentum used in these campaigns has been calibrated to a critical-rotation fraction. Neither a visually oblate model nor a small $J$ proves a particular fraction of critical rotation. The key global milestone is a relative virial error no larger than $10^{-5}$. The original July project README described an aspirational $10^{-6}$ target; the research acceptance target in this report is the subsequently specified $10^{-5}$. Internal pointwise correctness remains necessary. Exterior accuracy is required insofar as it supports the correct interior and boundary response; an independently accurate external field everywhere is not the immediate scientific objective. Nevertheless, the exterior formulation can influence interior gravity and cannot be disregarded merely because its own residual is small. The software objectives are equally explicit: retain a physics-oriented user API, express algorithm and field compatibility through types where practical, use runtime checks for mesh-dependent and state-dependent conditions, preserve independent density, and solve surface coefficients and interior fields in the same coupled system. Central density is an optional physical specification; it must not be silently imposed on every polytrope. Log density and new positivity enforcement are deferred. Existing optional feasibility experiments remain available for reproduction but are not enabled by consolidation. \subsection{What has actually been demonstrated} There is substantial progress, but the central rotating $n=3$ goal is open. The strongest established results are: \begin{enumerate} \item The native all-$m$, degree-four real spherical-harmonic surface prescription is integrated and tested against the corresponding nodal geometry, physical residuals and Jacobian actions. It reduces the surface to 25 independent coefficients without decoupling it from the interior solve. \item Some low-index, slowly rotating native-harmonic cases meet both their algebraic stopping criterion and the global virial target. Higher-index representation errors and unresolved pointwise checks prevent generalizing this to every algebraically converged case. \item At the same frozen state, gravity-Schur coupling reduced the measured total linear cost by 41.5 percent for $n=3,J=0$ and by 30.6 percent for $n=1.5,J=0.1$, at the stated true-defect gate. These are single matched comparisons, including setup, rather than statistical timing estimates. \item In the compatible rotating $n=3,J=0.035,K/K_0=0.99$ family, stellar LDU plus gravity-Schur reached a 12.687-times lower residual after ten updates than gravity-Schur alone, at 14.593 percent greater Newton time. This is an equal-update endpoint comparison, not a speedup to the same converged model. \item The best rotating $n=3$ endpoint still fails the full virial target: the enthalpy-pressure energy error is $1.81141\times10^{-5}$, and the density-pressure energy error is $3.51558\times10^{-5}$. Passing one force virial is insufficient. \item Physical-plane slices now show independent density and enthalpy on the actual deformed stellar geometry, with signed values and the undeformed outline available for comparison. Export refinement has been checked for selected $n=2$ and rotating $n=1.5$ states; it is not a mesh-convergence proof. \end{enumerate} Several attractive paths did not justify promotion: simple one-way material-to-gravity completion, increasing displacement order alone, expensive coarse surface/scalar corrections, and universal use of second-order trial corrections. Some improve an isolated metric while increasing total work or worsening the accepted nonlinear trajectory. Those negative results are preserved because they constrain the next design, not because the algorithms are impossible to improve. \subsection{How to use this record} The report first reconstructs the baseline and sequence of hypotheses, then describes the current implementation, numerical evidence and interpretation. Later sections distinguish active defaults from selectable experimental policies and record the consolidation checks. The source reports under \nolinkurl{experiments/} provide the most direct detailed companion records. \nolinkurl{reports/archive/} contains branch and relocation inventories. \nolinkurl{working/research/diagnostics/} contains the preserved raw campaigns. The large raw archive is local and intentionally not committed to Git; a source-only clone will not contain its saved models or copied executables. Versioned figure copies and this report remain usable without that archive. \section{Definitions and evidence discipline} \subsection{Physical variables and virial diagnostics} For the polytropic experiments, pressure obeys \begin{equation} P(\rho)=K\rho^{1+1/n},\qquad h(\rho)=(n+1)K\rho^{1/n},\qquad \rho_\star(h)=\left(\frac{h}{(n+1)K}\right)^n \label{eq:report-polytrope} \end{equation} on their physical nonnegative domains. The discrete density and enthalpy are independent finite-element fields; the weak closure equation does not make them pointwise equal. Consequently an integral formed from $P(\rho_h)$ need not agree with one formed from $P(h_h)$ at the same discrete state. Undefined fractional powers of negative density must be reported as undefined, not silently replaced with a positive or clipped value. For a zero-pressure stellar boundary, define \begin{equation} T=\frac12\int_{\mathcal{D}_\star}\rho \lvert \boldsymbol{v}\rvert^2\,dV, \qquad \Pi=\int_{\mathcal{D}_\star}P\,dV, \qquad W_\Phi=\frac12\int_{\mathcal{D}_\star}\rho\Phi\,dV. \end{equation} With the usual negative gravitational potential, $W_\Phi<0$. The force binding integral $W_f$ uses the corresponding gravitational force moment and agrees with $W_\Phi$ for a consistent isolated equilibrium. The campaign observers report energy and force virials using the common normalization $\lvert W_\Phi\rvert$: \begin{equation} v_\Phi=\frac{2T+3\Pi+W_\Phi}{\lvert W_\Phi\rvert},\qquad v_f=\frac{2T+3\Pi+W_f}{\lvert W_\Phi\rvert}. \label{eq:report-virials} \end{equation} Tables generally show their absolute values unless signs are explicitly given. A nonzero external pressure requires the boundary-pressure term; the stated campaign comparisons use the zero-pressure surface convention. Both pressure reconstructions and both gravity forms are retained where they are defined. Agreement at quadrature orders 14 and 18 is an integration consistency check on a fixed discrete state, not evidence of spatial convergence or exact pointwise physics. The common campaign scale is $M=R_{\rm reference}=G=1$ unless a manifest states otherwise. Angular momentum $J$, angular velocity, $T/\lvert W\rvert$, radius and critical-rotation fraction are different quantities. The physical-family compatibility study later explains why this distinction is particularly important at $n=3$. \subsection{Algebraic quantities and cost accounting} Let $x$ denote the complete normalized coupled coordinate vector and $F(x)$ its normalized residual. Write $A=DF(x)$ for its Jacobian; this notation avoids confusing the Jacobian with the stellar angular momentum $J$. A Newton correction $p$ is checked through the fresh full-system defect \begin{equation} \eta_{\rm true}=\frac{\lVert F(x)+Ap\rVert}{\lVert F(x)\rVert}. \label{eq:report-linear-defect} \end{equation} An internal Krylov recurrence or a reduced-system residual cannot substitute for this full-system endpoint test. The nonlinear merit function is $\mathcal{M}(x)=\tfrac12\lVert F(x)\rVert^2$; its directional derivative is $F(x)^T A p$. Linear success and a negative initial merit derivative do not guarantee acceptance of a finite step on a curved coupled path. The state and residual norms are produced by the configured physical Riesz normalization. They should not be compared across a change of basis, field order or normalization as though they were the same physical norm. The experiments therefore retain physical residual checks and integrals in addition to normalized algebraic quantities. A block's fraction of $\lVert F\rVert^2$ is an algebraic attribution; it is not an elementwise PDE error estimate. Frozen comparisons hold the complete base state, Jacobian, right-hand side, mesh and coordinates fixed. Their relevant linear cost includes construction, binding, setup, solve and a fresh endpoint verification. Live comparisons follow evolving nonlinear states and include preparation, accepted/rejected trials and auxiliary solves in the recorded Newton time. Process wall time can additionally include observers and export overhead. Setup amortization must therefore be demonstrated on an actual repeated-use path rather than assumed from a smaller outer iteration count. \subsection{Controls, provenance and limits of inference} The adopted methodology used an isolated branch for each hypothesis or a clearly identified cumulative integration branch. A source revision and configuration were recorded before numerical work; campaign runners copied the executable, recorded its digest and retained the exact commands, mesh digest, saved state and block diagnostics. Builds, FEM runs and timing trials were serialized within the later controlled studies. Read-only analysis and source review could proceed independently. Single-run timings are reported as observations; no confidence interval or cross-machine performance claim is inferred from them. The pressure/shape investigations separated preparation feasibility, linear accuracy, initial descent and finite-step curvature. Derivative probes used directional or centered differences over a stated step grid and compared full versus component actions. Later snapshot loaders check dimensions, mesh, coordinate conventions and provenance rather than accepting a vector solely because its length matches. Unconverged restarts require an explicit diagnostic override. Saved-state initialization prepares and refreshes before committing, clears stale warm starts and rolls back failed initialization. The evidence checkers reject corrupt or inconsistent fixtures as well as accepting valid ones. Passing an artifact audit establishes consistency of the recorded experiment under that checker's contract. It does not establish that the nonlinear model converged, that all interior samples are physical, or that a target virial was attained. Similarly, passing code assertions is not equivalent to obtaining a validated stellar model. All finite iteration budgets and diagnostic ceilings remain explicit. A late small-step trajectory can be described as a stall observed over the available window. It cannot be promoted to a mathematically established convergence floor. Dense quadrature samples can locate negativity but cannot certify its absence everywhere; interval subdivision and polynomial bounds have their own scope and unresolved cases. Conclusions in this report retain those distinctions. \section{Starting point, problem definition, and architecture} The work began on 16 September 2026 with an already substantial experimental finite-element code. Its purpose was to discover a reliable numerical route to three-dimensional steady stellar equilibria before a later, independently written general-EOS implementation. The immediate physical model was a self-gravitating, rigidly rotating barotrope with a free stellar surface. The presence of older transport, Coriolis, viscosity, and continuity components did not mean that those equations participated in the active equilibrium solve. This distinction remains important when comparing the experimental code with the broader physics ultimately desired from a stellar structure application. The incoming Git HEAD was \texttt{75cc63873992984966ea20011cc04d9984f54be4}. It did not uniquely describe the audited source: 49 tracked files already differed, with 3,626 additions and 267 deletions, and additional untracked experiments and results were present. The later baseline commit \texttt{80cc3d8} on \nolinkurl{research/baseline-20260916} preserved that optimized source. The initial architecture audit was read-only. The subsequent diagnosis used fresh Release builds rather than assuming that existing executables represented the modified source. This provenance distinction is essential: historical binaries and historical passing tests are evidence about their own source, not automatically about the current checkout. The user reported approximately a tenfold reduction in the cost of an ordinary nonrotating $n=1$ Newton step, to about twenty seconds. Fresh measurements found 22--24 seconds for the first three accepted steps and were consistent with that operating point. The old pre-optimization source was not rerun in a matched comparison; the full historical factor of ten was therefore not independently remeasured. The inherited 9 September report had separately measured factors of 1.53 in whole-process time, 1.70 in Newton time, and 2.02 in linear-solve time for its particular batch. Later tensor, cache, and compact-action changes had different baselines. These gains must not be multiplied together. \subsection{Continuum equations and independent discrete fields} For a polytrope of index $n\geq1$ and constant $K>0$, \begin{align} P&=K\rho^{1+1/n}, & h&=(n+1)K\rho^{1/n}, & \rho_{\mathrm{EOS}}(h)&=\left[\frac{h}{(n+1)K}\right]^n, \qquad h\geq0. \end{align} With positive centrifugal potential $\Psi=\lvert\boldsymbol\Omega\mathbin{\times}\boldsymbol x\rvert^2/2$, the Bernoulli imbalance is \begin{equation} B=h+\Phi-\Psi-C. \end{equation} The gravity flux represents $\boldsymbol g=\nabla\Phi$, so physical gravitational acceleration is $-\boldsymbol g$. The active system combines a mixed gradient--potential gravity formulation, a weak density closure, weak Bernoulli balance, reduced mechanical virtual work, and integral constraints for total mass and axial angular momentum. Density, enthalpy, potential, and the gravity flux are independent finite-element fields. In particular, the mechanical pressure is evaluated from enthalpy while gravity and centrifugal forces use independent density. Continuum equivalence of these quantities does not force their pointwise equality after discretization. The surface condition replaces the relevant enthalpy test rows by the enthalpy value corresponding to prescribed surface pressure. At zero surface pressure this is an $h=0$ trace condition. The mechanical residual is first formed against volume displacements and then pulled back by the transpose of the surface-to-volume deformation derivative. If $q$ denotes independent surface parameters and $D(q)$ the generated displacement, its schematic form is \begin{equation} R_s(q,u)=D'(q)^T R_{\mathrm{mech}}(D(q),u). \end{equation} The Jacobian includes both the derivative of the mechanical force and the derivative of this pullback. A zero $R_s$ proves equilibrium only against the chosen extension-generated mechanical tests; it does not set every unrestricted volume mechanical row to zero. The usual initial example additionally imposed a central-density specification. Its actual row was a central enthalpy point condition, \begin{equation} R_c=h(0)-h(\rho_{c,\mathrm{target}}),\qquad R_h\longleftarrow R_h+\lambda_c e_c. \end{equation} It was not a direct point condition on the independent discontinuous density. This distinction motivated measuring the unbordered residual and artificial source amplitude. The user clarified that the central condition should remain optional, principally useful for the $n=3$ homology, and should not be automatically inserted at other indices or hidden in a physics-facing API. \subsection{Discretization and model compilation} The common mesh had 1,216 hexahedra: 832 stellar and 384 vacuum elements. Its SHA-256 was \nolinkurl{ce11ae99e21e6c3bbfbee402acd2e191c1da0d8261d2227b4203f73f2f337a74}. Reference geometry was order four. The ordinary spaces were RT index two for gravity, discontinuous $Q_2$ for potential and stellar density, and continuous $Q_3$ for enthalpy and displacement. The original scalar nodal radial surface had 866 parameters. With its three scalar constraints the root had 178,074 unknowns; removing the central specification removed one scalar, yielding 178,073. Mesh geometry order and the approximation order of an individual physical field were distinct controls. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{105mm}p{40mm}@{}} \hline Initial root block & Number of unknowns \\ \hline Gravity gradient & 98,928 \\ Potential & 32,832 \\ Stellar density & 22,464 \\ Stellar enthalpy & 22,981 \\ Nodal radial surface & 866 \\ Generated scalar coordinates & 3 \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The architecture was already strongly compositional. A compile-time model specification pack generated the block layout, scalar coordinates, Jacobian couplings, normalization metadata, and prepared specification runtimes. The active aggregate was the variadic prepared equilibrium operator. C++23 module interfaces under \nolinkurl{libmeanfield/interface} were separated from implementations under \nolinkurl{libmeanfield/impl}. MFEM/MPI spaces used explicit maps between supported solver coordinates and full true degrees of freedom. The nonlinear context owned accepted and trial states, normalization, inverse preparation, and linear backend; refresh, stale-view rejection, rollback, and observer lifetime were explicit contracts rather than informal conventions. Prepared matrix-free actions cached reference basis tables, geometry, thermodynamics, and local contractions. Their dependency identities and revisions controlled invalidation. The numerical work therefore emphasized reusing established ownership and preparation interfaces rather than adding ad hoc mutable solver state. Static choices such as block identities, compatible policy combinations, and registered capabilities were checked at compile time. Mesh sizes, rank agreement, actual FE eligibility, values, normalization factors, and preparation generations necessarily required runtime validation. The geometry map initially used nodal radial surface variation, a logical radius-squared interior extension, and a fixed-infinity vacuum extension. Kelvin compactification represented the exterior through infinity. The root geometry unknown was the surface, not the much larger volume displacement field. Surface parameterization, interpolation of displacement, extension, and the physical map were therefore distinct architectural responsibilities. The seed initialized density and enthalpy independently by finite-element coefficient interpolation of a spherical Lane--Emden profile, using MFEM's \texttt{ProjectCoefficient}, and solved mixed gravity separately. This initialization was distinct from solving the weak closure's weighted $L^2$ projection relation; the method name must not be read as implying such a mass-matrix solve. It set shape to zero, initialized $C$ from $-GM/R$, and initialized $\Omega$ from the target $J$ divided by spherical inertia. A seed with nonzero target $J$ was not an already rotating equilibrium. Throughout the early controlled campaign, $M=R_{\mathrm{reference}}=G=1$; at $n=1$, $K=2/\pi$ and $\rho_c=\pi/4$. Other indices used the production Lane--Emden integrator with step $10^{-3}$ to calibrate the seed. That was a consistent seed reference, not an independent high-precision continuum solution. \subsection{Physical acceptance and measurement conventions} The required milestone was virial balance within $10^{-5}$, together with credible interior fields. Exterior pointwise accuracy was not an independent goal; exterior errors mattered through their effect on stellar equilibrium. The campaign measured both gravitational energies \begin{equation} W_E=\frac12\int_\star\rho\Phi\,dV, \qquad W_F=-\int_\star\rho\,\boldsymbol x\cdot\nabla\Phi\,dV, \end{equation} and, for the zero-pressure surface, \begin{equation} \epsilon_V(W,P)= \frac{\left\lvert 2T+W+3\int_\star P\,dV\right\rvert}{\lvert W_E\rvert}. \end{equation} Pressure from $h$ and pressure from $\rho$ were evaluated separately, at independent diagnostic quadrature orders 14 and 18. Signed density was retained. When the EOS could not define pressure at a negative density sample, the full density-pressure diagnostic was reported undefined, rather than manufactured by clipping. Quadrature agreement tested integration sensitivity; it did not constitute spatial convergence or global positivity certification. The first physical checker required recorded nonlinear convergence and all eight finite virial measurements to satisfy $10^{-5}$. This conservative combined screen was stricter than a statement that a particular enthalpy-based virial passed. Neither passing the checker nor a small scalar virial alone was a pointwise continuum-accuracy certificate. Useful accompanying observations were mass and angular-momentum errors, Bernoulli variation, EOS mismatch, gravity consistency, geometry minima, density sign, and surface shape. No early value of $J$ or reference-unit $\Omega$ was calibrated as a fraction of critical rotation. The inherited saved $n=1,J=0$ benchmark already provided a useful physical reference beyond the scalar residual: density, enthalpy, interior potential, and gravity-gradient relative volume $L^2$ errors were approximately $4.70\,10^{-4}$, $3.27\,10^{-4}$, $1.26\,10^{-4}$, and $5.98\,10^{-4}$; surface-radius RMS error divided by reference radius was $2.75\,10^{-4}$. Its density-pressure energy virial was $3.10\,10^{-7}$ and mass error $2.36\,10^{-11}$. These were the particular saved coarse model's errors against its radial reference, not accuracy estimates for later rotating or higher-index cases. A one-level refined mesh and analytic geometry controls existed, but the corresponding directory did not contain completed refined equilibrium fields or an equilibrium convergence result. The audit did not infer completed mesh convergence from the presence of that directory. The historical full-suite XML contained 592 cases, 588 passing and four failing: centrifugal-virial refinement geometry, an $n=3$ projected-seed closure screen, and two- and four-rank MPI groups. Those failures had been reproduced in earlier preserved binaries. They were neither silently removed nor treated as fresh validation of the incoming modified source. At the initial audit, twelve production source files were newer than the available release sandbox binary and thirty newer than the test binary. This motivated the subsequent explicit rebuilds and targeted regression ledgers. A previous between-sample mesh fold was also documented, but the later saved $n=1$ mesh had healthier sampled geometry; it was not assumed to suffer the same demonstrated folding mechanism. \paragraph{Evidence.} The original workspace reports were \nolinkurl{reports/sources/original_audits/MeanField_audit_2026-09-16.md}, \nolinkurl{reports/sources/original_audits/MeanField_solver_diagnosis_2026-09-16.md}, and \nolinkurl{reports/sources/original_audits/formulation_audit_notes.md}. Their archival relocation is recorded in the consolidation manifest. Repository evidence includes \nolinkurl{experiments/POLYTROPE_VALIDATION_FINDINGS_2026-09-09.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/POLYTROPE_H_CONVERGENCE_2026-09-09.md}, and \nolinkurl{experiments/NUMERICAL_CAMPAIGN_2026-09-16.md}. \section{Initial diagnosis: several different plateaus} \subsection{Fresh control measurements} The diagnostic rebuilt the incoming optimized source in Release using Homebrew Clang 22.1.8, with IPO enabled, profiling disabled, and uniform field order increment zero. Cases ran serially on one MPI rank. Initial live controls used FGMRES restart 40, at most 200 linear iterations, relative forcing tolerance $\eta=0.03$, nonlinear relative tolerance $10^{-8}$ and zero absolute tolerance. The nonlinear threshold was relative to the initial residual, not an absolute $10^{-8}$ requirement. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{26mm}p{24mm}p{35mm}p{59mm}@{}} \hline Model & Accepted updates & Retained $\lVert F\rVert$ & $P(h)$ energy/force virials \\ \hline $n=1,J=0$ & 3 full & $6.6053\,10^{-9}$ & $2.616\,10^{-7}/3.246\,10^{-7}$ \\ $n=1,J=0.01$ & 4 full & $5.0898\,10^{-10}$ & $2.610\,10^{-7}/3.246\,10^{-7}$ \\ $n=1,J=0.05$ & 5 full & $6.0406\,10^{-9}$ & $3.016\,10^{-7}/3.188\,10^{-7}$ \\ $n=1.5,J=0$ & $1,1/16$ & $1.6976\,10^{-4}$ & $2.245\,10^{-6}/2.318\,10^{-6}$ \\ $n=3,J=0$ & 0 & $3.1006\,10^{-3}$ & $5.326\,10^{-5}/8.341\,10^{-5}$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } All these controls stopped at a failed linear gate. The $n=3$ measurement was the unchanged seed. At $n=1,J=0$ the strict target was approximately $1.81\,10^{-12}$, whereas an earlier validation driver accepted the same three-step state under an absolute $10^{-8}$ threshold. These descriptions were consistent; they did not imply that a previously converged model had become physically invalid. Conversely, the $n=1$ seed itself already passed the virial threshold, directly demonstrating why virial alone was not a complete equilibrium test. The initial audit separated three mechanisms: loss of useful Krylov information late in otherwise accurate $n=1$ solves; stronger coupled linear difficulty at higher index; and severe nonlinear curvature or admissibility restrictions after a usable linear direction was obtained. It did not find evidence for one universal numerical floor. \subsection{Normalization audit} The state and residual registrations supplied their own physical scales and reference Gram diagonals. Writing these as $s_x,d_{x,i}$ for a value block and $s_F,d_{F,i}$ for its residual/test block, ordinary coefficient factors were \begin{equation} S_{ii}=\frac{\sqrt{d_{x,i}}}{s_x},\qquad L_{ii}=\frac{1}{s_F\sqrt{d_{F,i}}}. \end{equation} The Gram factors form paired primal and dual maps where the registered function-space topologies correspond, but the physical scales need not agree. For example, surface parameters use a length scale while mechanical shape residuals use a force scale; potential uses specific energy while its Poisson residual uses inverse time squared. Point replacement rows and scalar blocks have their declared special treatment. These distinctions are explicit in \nolinkurl{libmeanfield/interface/normalization/physical_riesz.cppm}. The reference factors were frozen through a solve. Their characteristic scales came from $M,R_{\mathrm{reference}},G$ and did not divide by the requested angular momentum $J$; zero rotation was therefore not a normalization singularity. Let $\widehat x=Sx$ and $\widehat F=LF$. The consistent transformations were \begin{equation} \widehat A=LAS^{-1},\qquad \widehat P^{-1}=SP^{-1}L^{-1},\qquad \widehat A\widehat P^{-1}=LAP^{-1}L^{-1}. \end{equation} Consequently, changing only state scales cancels from a consistently right-preconditioned system. Direct probes multiplying block state scales by $10^{-3}$ through $10^3$ preserved the physical correction and preconditioned action to approximately $10^{-16}$. Wrapper/explicit actions and coordinate round trips agreed at roundoff. This ruled against a basic scaling-wrapper implementation error at the inspected states. It did not show that the chosen residual norm was optimal: changing $L$ changes what both Krylov and line search minimize. The same $M=R=G=1$ factors were used across indices despite changing stellar concentration. Large factor ranges alone did not diagnose a bug. Similarly, small normalized border matrices had raw condition numbers $2.78\,10^7$ and $9.69\,10^7$, dominated by a central-column scale near $7.3\,10^6$; diagnostic equilibration reduced these to about 1.46 and 2.39. Those were border-matrix observations, not the condition number of the full stellar Jacobian or proof of a singular physical system. \subsection{Central condition: a useful example correction} At $n=1,J=0.05$, matched restart-40 runs with and without the central condition had identical first five accepted step lengths and linear iteration counts. Both then failed the sixth linear gate near relative defect 0.505. Removing the condition nevertheless markedly improved localized physical consistency: {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{70mm}p{38mm}p{38mm}@{}} \hline Quadrature-18 measurement & With central condition & Without \\ \hline Peak absolute EOS density mismatch & $7.30451\,10^{-3}$ & $3.32568\,10^{-4}$ \\ Peak mismatch / sampled density scale & $9.33951\,10^{-3}$ & $4.30594\,10^{-4}$ \\ Bernoulli sampled range & $1.45751\,10^{-2}$ & $1.30398\,10^{-3}$ \\ Unbordered residual & $4.54227\,10^{-6}$ & $6.03609\,10^{-9}$ \\ $P(h)$ energy virial & $3.01617\,10^{-7}$ & $3.06913\,10^{-7}$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The formerly fixed central enthalpy changed from 1 to 0.983383508. Mass, angular momentum, angular velocity, and volume RMS errors changed little. The result supported removing that artificial restriction from the $n=1$ example, while leaving explicit central constraints available. It did not establish that central constraints caused the general plateau. \subsection{Krylov window and warm-guess safeguard} Frozen cold comparisons retained the same state, full Jacobian, physical right-hand side, and inverse. Increasing only the restart window from 40 to 160 gave: {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{70mm}p{38mm}p{38mm}@{}} \hline Frozen state & Window 40: iterations / defect & Window 160: iterations / defect \\ \hline $n=1,J=0$ endpoint & $200/0.04442$ & $72/0.02914$ \\ $n=1,J=0.01$ endpoint & $200/0.35468$ & $125/0.02519$ \\ $n=1.5,J=0$ endpoint & $200/0.06491$ & $70/0.02694$ \\ $n=3,J=0$ seed & $200/0.05631$ & $200/0.04026$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } For the rotating $n=1$ state, histories coincided through iteration 40 and separated immediately after restart. Independently recomputed full residuals agreed with reported residuals. This established actual loss of useful Krylov information, not false convergence reporting. In a live unbordered $n=1,J=0.05$ comparison, restart 160 reached strict convergence in seven full steps with $F=3.38036\,10^{-11}$, versus five steps and $6.03609\,10^{-9}$ before linear failure with restart 40. Total linear iterations were 292 versus 370; complete diagnostic-process times were 271.95 versus 290.80 seconds. All eight virial checks were below $3.735\,10^{-7}$. These were single timing observations with increased Krylov storage, not a universal speedup claim. The solver reused $(1-\alpha)p$ after a damped update as the next initial linear guess. This was vector reuse, not Krylov recycling. At one $n=1.5$ state that guess had a true defect larger than the zero guess. A small backend safeguard now checks the current true defect of a supplied nonzero guess and discards it only if the norm is nonfinite or exceeds $\lVert b\rVert$. Nonfinite input coefficients remain an input-contract error. The guard adds one action for a nonzero guess and none for a zero guess, without a new public option. The matched $n=1$ output was bitwise unchanged. At $n=1.5$, the first shared guarded solve reduced the effective initial defect/RHS from 1.5097 to 1 and iterations from 71 to 65. Over eight attempts the control had seven successful linear solves followed by failure; the guard passed all eight. Total iterations fell from 672 to 561, mostly by avoiding that failed 200-iteration attempt. The endpoint changed only from $1.75135\,10^{-4}$ to $1.74946\,10^{-4}$, a 0.108 percent improvement, with final steps $1/2048$ and $1/8192$. This was a modest inner-solver robustness improvement, not a cure for nonlinear stagnation. \subsection{Rejected one-way gravity completion} The first coupling hypothesis changed the structure inverse from independent material/gravity blocks to material-then-gravity triangular completion. It retained the material inverse, order-five Chebyshev flux-mass inverse, and three AMG cycles, and rebuilt the scalar border consistently. At the same centrally constrained $n=3$ seed, the restart-160 defect changed from 0.0402590 to 0.0381781 after 200 iterations; both failed $\eta=0.03$. Time increased from 98.92 to 117.71 seconds, correction norm from 0.75764 to 1.54083, and the sampled thermodynamic step limit worsened from 0.15244 to 0.09135. The candidate's $\alpha=0.1$ trial was inadmissible. This particular one-way completion was not promoted. The baseline restart-40 and restart-160 corrections had cosine $-0.985$ despite the same matrix and right-hand side. Their difference had a response bound $\lVert A(p_2-p_1)\rVert/\lVert p_2-p_1\rVert\leq2.77\,10^{-4}$. This established a weak measured direction, not a singular value or an identification of homology, translation, or a surface mode. Later studies therefore examined the actual coupled directions instead of adding a gauge on analogy alone. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/NUMERICAL_CAMPAIGN_2026-09-16.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/CENTRAL_CONSTRAINT_HYPOTHESIS_2026-09-16.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/KRYLOV_WINDOW_HYPOTHESIS_2026-09-16.md}, and \nolinkurl{experiments/KRYLOV_HYPOTHESIS_2026-09-16.md}. The combined nonrotating $n=1$ case subsequently reached $F=1.65157\,10^{-13}$ in six full steps with worst virial $3.73092\,10^{-7}$. The transfer case $n=1,J=0.1$ passed all twelve linear gates but ended at $6.25389278\,10^{-3}$, with final $\alpha=4.76837\,10^{-7}$ and failing enthalpy-based virials $4.75186\,10^{-4}/8.18118\,10^{-4}$. That transfer failure motivated the next investigation. \section{Separating pressure preparation from shape-related curvature} The focused 17 September campaign made no production numerical changes. It captured exact trial states, identified rejection stages, and split the same Newton correction into its actual shape block $p_s$ and all remaining fields and scalars $p_f$. Frozen replays restored the base before each action; probing a trial never committed it as an accepted model. \subsection{The rotating pressure obstruction was localized and real} At $n=1,J=0.1$, exact replays of the first rejected candidates at zero-based iterations 2, 3, 4, 7, and 11 all returned the production code \texttt{thermodynamic\_domain / pressure\_force / outside\_domain}. The pressure source takes this branch for finite negative enthalpy. Thus these were enthalpy-domain failures, not inverted geometry. The limiting pressure point remained at local stellar element 459, quadrature point 50; the closure's different rule limited at point 36 of the same element. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{14mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}@{}} \hline Iteration & Pressure-point $h$ & $\delta h$ & Pressure bound & Accepted $\alpha$ \\ \hline 2 & $9.63674\,10^{-4}$ & $-1.31441\,10^{-2}$ & $7.33159\,10^{-2}$ & $1/16$ \\ 3 & $1.42165\,10^{-4}$ & $-2.11119\,10^{-3}$ & $6.73390\,10^{-2}$ & $1/16$ \\ 4 & $1.02159\,10^{-5}$ & $-1.89704\,10^{-3}$ & $5.38520\,10^{-3}$ & $1/256$ \\ 7 & $7.04574\,10^{-8}$ & $-1.86569\,10^{-3}$ & $3.77648\,10^{-5}$ & $1/32768$ \\ 11 & $1.07227\,10^{-9}$ & $-1.86493\,10^{-3}$ & $5.74963\,10^{-7}$ & $1/2097152$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The pressure step budget fell by a factor of 127,514 while the late negative direction remained finite. The limiting element touched the stellar surface; the pressure point's reference Cartesian radius was 0.997553, near the negative rotation pole, approximately 8.66 degrees from the negative $z$ axis at onset. It was an interior quadrature point, not a boundary row. Topological adjacency did not measure distance to the deformed surface. At onset the closure bound, 0.0727489, was slightly tighter than the pressure bound; pressure was evaluated first and therefore reported first when both failed. A deliberately intermediate trial at $\alpha=0.07303236911639208$ passed pressure preparation and failed closure, with predicted closure $h=-5.01979\,10^{-6}$ and limiting pressure $h=+3.72619\,10^{-6}$. This showed why a first rejection stage must not be confused with the tightest thermodynamic constraint. All 866 surface enthalpy coefficients and their directions were exactly zero at onset and late capture. Boundary leakage was excluded for these trials. Nevertheless, positive nodal values did not imply a positive represented polynomial. A step just beyond the onset bound retained nonnegative values at all 64 local $Q_3$ nodes while making interior pressure and closure samples negative. At the late state even a unit step retained nonnegative nodes but gave $h=-1.86493\,10^{-3}$ at the limiting pressure point. An independent reconstruction of the local tensor polynomial reproduced the nodes exactly and limiting-point values within $6.94\,10^{-18}$. A much denser grid found that the late accepted base already had negative enthalpy: a sampled minimum $-2.87114\,10^{-5}$ at reference coordinates $(0.0130467,0.515625,0.01)$. A separate 60-digit reconstruction agreed with the negative value at another selected interior point. These findings proved negative values existed in that element; the reported minimum was not a certified global minimum. Passing production quadrature preparation was thus not a pointwise positivity certificate. They also did not prove that every low-rotation or nonrotating converged control shared this defect. \subsection{Higher-index merit rejection had a different mechanism} For any directional piece $p_d$, the diagnostic measured \begin{equation} R_d(\alpha)=F(x+\alpha p_d)-F(x)-\alpha Ap_d, \qquad R_{\mathrm{mixed}}=R_{\mathrm{full}}-R_s-R_f. \end{equation} The mixed vector was formed before taking norms. All pieces used common step lengths and the original, unrenormalized block amplitudes. With $L=F+\alpha Ap$, the exact merit identity was \begin{equation} \lVert F(x+\alpha p)\rVert^2= \lVert L\rVert^2+2\langle L,R_{\mathrm{full}}\rangle +\lVert R_{\mathrm{full}}\rVert^2. \end{equation} At $n=1.5,J=0$, captured iteration 1, the raw full trial was admissible with minimum sampled Jacobian 0.896116. Its linear prediction was only 0.02576812 of the base norm; the actual residual was 12.243161 times the base norm. At $\alpha=0.1$ the actual ratio remained 1.02052 rather than the predicted 0.900070; at 0.01 it decreased to 0.991209. This established nonlinear merit failure separately from the rotating thermodynamic wall. Gravity-gradient actions from shape and fields had norms 0.115959 and 0.116055, cosine $-0.999999831$, and combined norm $1.16990\,10^{-4}$. Poisson actions also nearly cancelled, with cosine $-0.999996055$. Damping shape alone would have destroyed this measured first-order balance. The full-step second-order remainder was $2.18903\,10^{-3}$, with 99.7747 percent of its squared norm in gravity. Fixed-shape gravity is affine in its fields in the source; measured fields-only gravity remainders remained at arithmetic scale. Resolved remainders divided by $\alpha^2$ stabilized, consistent with the directional Jacobian rather than a persistent first-order derivative error. At the constrained $n=3$ seed the original correction still failed the $0.03$ forcing gate, attaining 0.0402590; it was not silently replaced by a better direction. At its common cap $\alpha=0.12194828$, the actual norm was 1.0237652 of the base versus prediction 0.87826014. Gravity accounted for 90.7812 percent of the squared remainder. At one tenth of this cap the trial decreased the residual, and the net curvature contribution was slightly favorable. A large mixed term therefore did not imply that its signed merit projection was always adverse. The consequence was to keep feasibility and nonlinear path curvature as separate hypotheses. A sampled enthalpy cap could avoid futile trials but would not remove a wall where $h\to0$ and $\delta h<0$. Nor could exterior weighting be justified from whole-gravity-block norms alone: the original probes had not yet localized stellar versus exterior contributions. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/PRESSURE_AND_SHAPE_CAMPAIGN_2026-09-17.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/PRESSURE_OBSTRUCTION_METHODOLOGY_2026-09-17.md}, and \nolinkurl{experiments/POLYNOMIAL_ENTHALPY_ADMISSIBILITY_2026-09-17.md}. The eight focused and two supplemental cases restored their base residuals exactly; direction partitions and signed-merit identities passed independent checks. No additional virial-qualified model was produced by these probes. \section{Three optional numerical strategies and their limits} The next implementation added three interchangeable numerical approaches: polynomial enthalpy feasibility, gravity curvature correction, and gravity elimination. They were selected by concrete typed policies through \texttt{NewtonNumerics}, not added to the physics-facing model declarations. Unregistered or incompatible policies failed compile-time constraints; actual mesh and FE eligibility were checked collectively at runtime. The ordinary Newton path remained available and defaults were unchanged. \subsection{Polynomial enthalpy certification and anchor repair} The diagnostic converted the represented nodal polynomial to a tensor Bernstein representation with outward-rounded interval arithmetic. Adaptive subdivision returned a nonnegativity certificate, a negative-value witness, or unresolved bounds. A negative Bernstein coefficient by itself was not misclassified as a negative polynomial. Exact zero traces were retained. Certification used physical enthalpy coordinates, because general diagonal normalization does not preserve the polynomial represented by the coefficients. For an admissible base, a fixed certified initial field supplied an anchor: \begin{equation} p_h(\beta)=(1-\beta)p_h+\beta(h_{\mathrm{anchor}}-h), \qquad0\leq\beta\leq1. \end{equation} Sufficient Bernstein inequalities constrained the repair fraction and the full linear residual model selected a fraction. The actual normalized-and-added candidate was certified again, and its complete merit derivative had to remain negative. This was a conservative feasible-direction family, not a constrained Newton optimizer, and it did not make the independent density positive. At the rotating onset the base certified and the original full trial was proved negative. Whole-mesh certification cost about 3--4 ms. The sufficient repair fraction was 0.9152726503; repaired polynomials prepared successfully, but trial lengths 1, 0.5, and 0.125 all increased the full residual. The linear model's best step was near 0.00825, with only about 0.46 percent predicted residual reduction. The already negative late base correctly returned \texttt{invalid\_base} and left accepted buffers unchanged. This path supplied useful diagnostic and admissibility machinery, but was not established as an efficient route through the nonlinear obstacle. The later user decision to defer positivity enforcement was consistent with this mixed result. \subsection{Gravity-only curvature correction} Partition the normalized state into retained variables $u$ and gravity variables $z$, with gravity equations $G(u,z)$. At a raw trial $y=x+\alpha p$, the correction solved \begin{equation} G_z(y)\,\delta z= -\bigl[G(y)-G(x)-\alpha G'(x)p\bigr]. \end{equation} Only gravity coordinates changed. This removes the nonlinear gravity remainder, not the entire gravity residual. It preserves the base tangent because the right-hand side is second order along a smooth path, and it vanishes on an affine gravity path even when the base residual is nonzero. The candidate inverse was refreshed, every residual was reevaluated, and ordinary full-merit acceptance remained authoritative. The first frozen $n=1.5$ comparison changed the full trial residual from $2.18913190375\,10^{-3}$ to $1.40702031008\,10^{-4}$ at base norm $1.78804469158\,10^{-4}$. The gravity remainder fell from $2.18656200516\,10^{-3}$ to $1.37482284578\,10^{-12}$, with observed correction order 1.999898 on the smallest resolved steps. This was direct evidence that the identified curvature could be removed from gravity. An initial production attempt was intentionally stopped after repeated auxiliary prepared-consistency rejection despite converged inner solves. The arithmetic allowance had omitted large cancelling gravity contributions. The revised check included separately measured gradient, potential, source, and correction actions; it used $256\epsilon$ times their norm sum as a heuristic allowance, not a rigorous error bound. The true inner gate, lifted full-Jacobian gate, nonlinear tolerance, and physical criteria were not relaxed. The interrupted run and correction history were preserved. \subsection{Gravity elimination} Gravity elimination instead completed gravity at the initial state and each retained trial, then used the reduced Schur action \begin{equation} S=F_u-F_zG_z^{-1}G_u. \end{equation} Right-hand-side condensation included the residual gravity defect, and lifting reconstructed a full correction that still had to satisfy the original full normalized linear gate. Tolerance-stopped inner Krylov solves only approximated this linear action; flexible outer preconditioning did not magically make it exact. Tight inner gates, finite-difference checks, and lifted verification were therefore retained. The reference implementation restricted the full operator and inverse. A capability-checked compact path reused the existing prepared physical gravity actions with the same scaling. On three dense actual-FEM directions compact and full-restricted outputs agreed exactly. Gravity operator applications cost about 0.018 versus 0.244 seconds, around fourteen times faster, while inverse applications changed only from approximately 0.205 to 0.160 seconds. A matched tight inner solve retained forty iterations and the same result while falling from 18.36 to 7.25 seconds. The fourteenfold action gain was not a fourteenfold Newton speedup. \subsection{Production outcomes of the three strategies} {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{55mm}p{24mm}p{32mm}p{35mm}@{}} \hline Model and path & Accepted updates & Final $\lVert F\rVert$ & Newton seconds / outcome \\ \hline $n=1,J=0$, curvature & 6 & $6.51136\,10^{-14}$ & 273.71 / converged \\ $n=1,J=0$, eliminated & 6 & $8.98743\,10^{-14}$ & 869.67 / converged \\ $n=1.5,J=0$, curvature & 6 & $1.48794\,10^{-5}$ & 711.72 / outer gate failure \\ $n=1.5,J=0$, eliminated & 5 & $4.47888\,10^{-6}$ & 1821.79 / completed updates only \\ $n=1,J=0.1$, polynomial & 3 & $7.13059\,10^{-3}$ & 265.03 / outer gate failure \\ Polynomial plus curvature & 1 & $8.40387\,10^{-3}$ & 127.05 / outer gate failure \\ Polynomial plus elimination & 1 & $2.72634\,10^{-2}$ & 149.83 / non-descent repair \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The two nonrotating $n=1$ gravity paths and polynomial control reached the same discrete model to coefficient differences below $2.632\,10^{-11}$. All eight virials were below $3.73092\,10^{-7}$; independent enthalpy certificates covered all 832 stellar elements. The eliminated control used 107 inner solves and 3,875 inner iterations, versus six solves and 115 iterations for curvature correction. It was a verified alternative, but substantially more expensive. The $n=1.5$ curvature run reduced the initial norm about eighteenfold but failed its seventh outer solve at relative defect 0.059017 after 200 iterations. All fourteen auxiliary solves passed. The eliminated run was externally interrupted at 2,400 seconds during its sixth attempt, after five accepted steps of $1,1/2,1/4,1/128,1/2048$. Its last accepted gravity residual was about $3.27\,10^{-14}$ while retained equations remained of order $10^{-6}$; the last step improved the total residual only 0.00565 percent. This showed stagnation despite completed gravity. No final snapshot or complete physical diagnostics existed for the timed-out run, so these were not invented from its log. Rotating runs remained both unconverged and virially unacceptable. The polynomial-only fourth linear attempt attained 0.0331634 rather than the required 0.03. Adding curvature improved the first step with the same tangent but the second linear solve failed at 0.0826534. Polynomial plus elimination passed its reduced and lifted linear gates before a repaired direction failed descent. A reporting replay later established that this failure occurred before another gravity relift, correcting an earlier ambiguous interpretation of counters. All these models retained negative independent density samples. The implementation was covered by 43 targeted serial cases and 1,886 assertions at the final revision, with 37 supported cases on each of two MPI ranks. Full stellar multi-rank operation was not thereby certified: logical radial surface interpolation and per-rank material ownership restrictions remained. The frozen checks established algebra and lifecycle invariants; they did not constitute physical convergence. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/NUMERICAL_STRATEGIES_2026-09-17.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/GRAVITY_SUBSYSTEM_IMPLEMENTATION_2026-09-17.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/GRAVITY_REDUCTION_IMPLEMENTATION_2026-09-17.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/GRAVITY_COMPACT_APPLICATIONS_2026-09-17.md}, and \nolinkurl{experiments/GRAVITY_PREPARED_ROUNDOFF_2026-09-17.md} retain the complete policy contracts, intermediate failed builds/runs, and replay history. \section{Preconditioner improvements measured at equal accuracy} \subsection{Baseline approximation and work accounting} The original inverse first treated surface and material through a triangular surface-then-enthalpy-then-density approximation. Surface used a reference mass diagonal; enthalpy used hydrostatic mass and identity treatment at replaced boundary rows; density included the live EOS enthalpy derivative. Material-to-surface feedback was omitted. Gravity used approximate mixed LDU with a degree-five Chebyshev mass inverse and three fixed AMG cycles for a potential surrogate. Structure-level material and gravity were independent, then a small dense scalar Schur complement completed specification borders relative to that approximate inverse. The live high-$n$ EOS derivative was present; there was no evidence that the baseline simply omitted it. Frozen benchmark roles each constructed fresh inverses and border responses at the same saved state, full Jacobian, normalization, and right-hand side. Reported complete verified cost included inverse construction, normalized binding, Krylov setup, solve, and an independent full-Jacobian endpoint action. Failed solves were retained but never used as finite baseline time-to-convergence measurements. Timing runs and large audits were serialized. \subsection{Prepared cross-action optimization} Existing stellar LDU was initially unexpectedly expensive: at an $n=1.5$ plateau, 200 iterations cost 599.5473 seconds versus 87.9302 for the independent baseline, and both failed the gate. The gravity-to-material coupling used a legacy geometry-evaluation path. Replacing it with the already prepared complete gravity-force action, with zero density and displacement variations, preserved the same mathematical gravity-gradient column and subsequent deformation adjoint. The cached LDU reduced complete cost to 117.4845 seconds, a factor 5.1032 relative to the old LDU path, and mean inverse application time by 8.0425. The correction changed only $2.7051\,10^{-11}$ relatively and the gate still failed at 0.0600669. This was an execution optimization, not a conditioning improvement. It deserved retention independently of whether LDU was selected as a numerical policy. \subsection{Mass-consistent gravity Schur refinement} Writing the mixed gravity block as \begin{equation} D=\begin{bmatrix}M&B^T\\B&0\end{bmatrix},\qquad D\begin{bmatrix}g\\\Phi\end{bmatrix}=\begin{bmatrix}f\\r_g\end{bmatrix}, \end{equation} let $R$ be the same approximate mass inverse used for flux recovery and $Q$ the existing AMG inverse on the diagonal-mass surrogate. The added policy used \begin{align} S_R&=BRB^T, & r&=BRf-r_g, & \Phi_0&=Qr,\\ \Phi_{j+1}&=\Phi_j+\omega Q(r-S_R\Phi_j), & g&=Rf-RB^T\Phi_k. \end{align} The Poisson defect was thereby measured against the same approximate mass action as recovery. This was still not an exact inverse of the mixed block. Fixed work preserved stationarity only when the child actions themselves declared stationary linear behavior. Positive relaxation alone did not prove contraction. Each extra sweep cost one application of $R,Q,B,B^T$; zero sweeps retained the old arithmetic path for bitwise baseline comparison. One sweep with $\omega=0.5$ first crossed the original $0.03$ gate at the $n=1.5$ saved state. An equal-accuracy confirmation gave: {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{55mm}p{22mm}p{34mm}p{29mm}@{}} \hline Inverse, frozen $n=1.5,J=0$ & Iterations & True relative defect & Complete cost (s) \\ \hline Independent baseline & 231 & 0.0290033753 & 100.9943 \\ Mass-consistent gravity Schur & 132 & 0.0292091550 & 72.3727 \\ \hline \end{longtable} } This was a measured 1.39548-fold speedup, 28.34 percent lower complete cost and 42.86 percent fewer iterations, without relaxing accuracy. At a saved $n=1,J=0.1$ system, the independent and gravity-only controls still failed after 600 iterations, at defects 0.0739197 and 0.0408506. Combining cached stellar LDU with gravity refinement passed in 142 iterations at defect 0.0299068971, complete cost 96.8236 seconds. It reduced Poisson and gradient defect norms by 63.33 and 94.47 percent relative to the matched 200-iteration independent control. Since the baseline had no finite observed successful solve, no rotating speedup ratio was asserted. A nine-mode coupled shape coarse inverse was a negative control. All modes were active, overlap/rank checks passed, and there was no fallback, but the 200-iteration defect worsened to 0.0668658. Setup added 8.6012 seconds and persistent vectors occupied 28,491,680 bytes. That failed candidate remained experimental; it did not rule out every possible coarse space. \subsection{Nonlinear transfer limited the recommendation} For easy $n=1,J=0$, both independent and gravity-refined inverses converged in six full steps to the same physical state, with all virials below $3.74\,10^{-7}$. Linear iterations fell from 307 to 258, yet Newton time rose from 191.068 to 199.375 seconds, 4.35 percent. More expensive inverse applications outweighed iteration reduction. For $n=1.5,J=0$ with gravity curvature correction, the stronger inverse passed all twelve permitted outer linear gates and all 31 auxiliary gravity solves. It removed the earlier immediate linear failure but ended at $1.3966991\,10^{-5}$, only 6.13 percent below the old six-update endpoint and far above target $2.7365922\,10^{-12}$. All nineteen rejections were merit failures, with late accepted steps $1/64$ and $1/512$. Newton time was 1075.368 seconds, including 415.038 in outer linear solves and 590.003 in preparation; nested auxiliary time must not be added again. Enthalpy-based virials passed, but negative density persisted. The rotating combined-inverse follow-through accepted one repaired full step to $0.00685562$, then failed the next linear gate at 0.0339685. Its enthalpy energy virial, 0.00712711, was worse than the historical independent endpoint's 0.000544539 despite its smaller nonlinear residual. Both failed physically. Frozen linear gains therefore did not justify claiming a solved nonlinear or physical problem, and the stronger policies remained optional. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/PRECONDITIONER_IMPROVEMENT_2026-09-18.md}, \nolinkurl{experiments/GRAVITY_CONSISTENT_SCHUR_2026-09-18.md}, and \nolinkurl{experiments/PRECONDITIONER_CACHED_CROSS_ACTION_2026-09-18.md}. Focused serial coverage passed 20 cases and 441,978 assertions; two-rank algebra/coarse tests passed thirteen cases per rank. The actual multi-rank FEM test was blocked by a pre-existing partition where one rank had no vacuum element, required by mapped H(div) construction. Refining the mesh did not remove that ownership pattern. Serial FEM evidence must not be described as distributed FEM validation. \section{Why better linear solves did not remove the nonlinear stall} The next frozen investigation used the saved $n=1.5,J=0$ endpoint with $\lVert F\rVert=1.3966991044\,10^{-5}$. All prior linear gates had passed; the final squared-residual shares were about 42.42 percent hydrostatic, 26.23 percent closure, 15.87 percent surface, 10.43 percent gravity, and 5.05 percent mass. It computed fresh cold directions rather than claiming to reconstruct raw directions that the earlier trajectory had not saved. For $\phi=\lVert F\rVert^2/2$ and a forcing condition $\lVert Ap+F\rVert\leq\eta\lVert F\rVert$, a consistent derivative gives \begin{equation} \phi'(0)=\langle F,Ap\rangle\leq-(1-\eta)\lVert F\rVert^2. \end{equation} Thus a gate-passing direction should be strongly locally descending, but this says nothing about how far the linear approximation remains useful. \subsection{Tenfold tighter forcing did not improve the useful step} {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{70mm}p{38mm}p{38mm}@{}} \hline Measurement & $\eta=0.03$ & $\eta=0.003$ \\ \hline Iterations & 84 & 143 \\ Cold linear seconds & 47.9374 & 81.6901 \\ Verified relative defect & 0.0295592 & 0.00294840 \\ Direction norm & 0.0794897 & 0.0796012 \\ Corrected residual/base at $1/64$ & 1.080323 & 1.080567 \\ Corrected residual/base at $1/256$ & 1.002025 & 1.002037 \\ Corrected residual/base at $1/1024$ & 0.999394139 & 0.999394272 \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The tenfold stricter gate cost about seventy percent more linear work and left the useful sampled step essentially unchanged. The directions differed by only 0.8885 percent in norm and had cosine 0.99996157. A supplementary minimum-norm calculation in their two-dimensional span, subject to the original forcing gate, gained only 0.00058549 percent beyond ordinary scalar damping of the tighter direction. This was a saved-vector algebra experiment, not a fresh FEM trial, and did not rule out richer subspaces. Raw trials at $1,1/4,1/16$ failed pressure preparation for this new late direction. At $1/64$, raw and gravity-corrected residual ratios were 1.807268 and 1.080323; at $1/256$, 1.002510 and 1.002025. At $1/1024$ both decreased, to 0.999170 and 0.999394. The remainders were resolved and approximately quadratic over the small-step range. No persistent first-order error was detected in the tested tangent. \subsection{A large compensated direction amplified moderate curvature} The separate shape and field action norms were 0.7730368 and 0.7730377, while their sum had norm $1.396089\,10^{-5}$. The image cosine was $-0.999999999838$, and the cancellation factor was approximately 110,743. At the seed, the corresponding factor had been about 332.1. Normalization factors were byte-identical across these states. The late direction was 17.35 times larger while the residual was 19.59 times smaller. The ratio $\lVert p\rVert/\lVert F\rVert$ grew from 16.7433 to 5691.26, about 340-fold. At the common step $1/64$, corrected curvature per squared direction norm grew only from 0.656881 to 0.926040, about 1.41-fold; curvature relative to the base residual grew about 8,313-fold. This pointed toward weak coupled response and large corrections as the amplification mechanism, rather than orders-of-magnitude growth of curvature per unit direction. It did not identify a continuum symmetry or estimate the full Hessian. Gravity correction reduced the small-step remainder norm by about 14.7-fold at $1/1024$, but increased its adverse projection onto the linear predictor 2.88-fold. Hydrostatic, closure, surface, and mass rows contributed 43.52, 32.33, 19.53, and 4.63 percent of that signed projection. A smaller remainder therefore need not produce better merit. The observed full/shape gain ratio also gave a condition-number lower bound of about $9.07\,10^4$ if the finite-dimensional Jacobian was nonsingular; it was not a measured global condition number or a license to add a central constraint at $n=1.5$. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/NONLINEAR_STEP_INVESTIGATION_2026-09-18.md}. Three immutable probes covered 144 path observations and sixty successful auxiliary gravity solves; final saved-artifact audits passed 20,899 checks. All states, factors, and restored actions were preserved. Those checks established provenance and arithmetic identities, not a new model. \section{Fully coupled second-order trial corrections} \subsection{Bounded correction against the complete residual} Because gravity-only correction moved adverse curvature into retained equations, a fully coupled trial correction was implemented. At a prepared trial $y$, it preserved the original affine target $L(\alpha)=F_0+\alpha A_0p$ and solved \begin{equation} A(y)c=L(\alpha)-F(y). \end{equation} The auxiliary backend had its own true full-Jacobian defect check, finite budget, and report. The correction was capped by $\lVert c\rVert\leq\alpha\lVert p\rVert$ by default. It was attempted only after a prepared candidate failed ordinary acceptance, with at most one solve per Newton iteration initially. A failed solve, cap, admissibility test, or merit comparison restored the original trial with fresh preparation. Accepted-state buffers were not mutated by the transaction. The policy composed statically with existing enthalpy/gravity choices and deliberately rejected the unimplemented eliminated-gravity combination at compile time. At the common late state, the original direction still passed with defect 0.02955918315. Independent frozen trials showed: {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{40mm}p{22mm}p{22mm}p{22mm}p{30mm}@{}} \hline Path and $\alpha$ & Before/base & After/base & Auxiliary iterations & Added seconds \\ \hline Raw, $1/64$ & 1.80726810 & 1.03360191 & 34 & 27.33 \\ Raw, $1/256$ & 1.00250966 & 0.99746464 & 52 & 37.59 \\ Gravity first, $1/64$ & 1.08032296 & 1.09566246 & 55 & 47.60 \\ Gravity first, $1/256$ & 1.00202482 & 0.99810801 & 62 & 43.53 \\ \hline \end{longtable} } All auxiliary solves passed their unchanged gate and cap. The $1/256$ trials became acceptable, while the gravity-first $1/64$ trial worsened and was restored. The already acceptable $1/1024$ and seed full-step controls incurred no coupled solve. Raw timing came from an uncontended repeat after a mistakenly overlapping artifact audit was stopped and fixed; fifty saved vector files matched the first run byte-for-byte, and the original timing was excluded. The correction's own curvature remained significant. For $b=L-F(y)$, $\delta=A(y)c-b$, and $E=F(y+c)-F(y)-A(y)c$, \begin{equation} F(y+c)-L=\delta+E. \end{equation} At $1/256$, $\lVert E\rVert$ exceeded the verified auxiliary defect by about 11.28 for the raw path and 254 for the gravity-first path. Correction/direction cosines were $-0.9999330$ and $-0.9999942$: much of the correction reversed the original step. Actual displacement increases relative to the old $1/1024$ path were only 1.7596 and 1.2342, not the nominal factor four in $\alpha$. Fresh scalar controls matched projection along the original direction. They decreased residual 0.115623 and 0.096934 percent, whereas the coupled candidates decreased 0.253536 and 0.189199 percent. Small transverse components therefore had a measured benefit; the improvement was not just scalar damping. It remained a small absolute gain purchased with another coupled solve. Moreover, the independent frozen alphas each had a fresh correction budget, so this screen did not measure a live shared-budget line search. \subsection{Damping and work-aware eligibility} The next optional policy reused one computed $c$ across $\beta=1,1/2,1/4,1/8$, always preparing $y+\beta c$ from the same $y$. The first ordinarily acceptable improvement ended the search; otherwise the best admissible improvement could be retained as a trial, with fresh replay. An eligibility rule reserved the single solve for a candidate near the affine prediction. For the configured deterministic merit $M$, it required positive finite $D=M(F_0)-M(L)$ and \begin{equation} \frac{M(F(y))-M(F_0)}{D}\leq k,\qquad k=1\ \hbox{by default}. \end{equation} This was a bounded-work heuristic, not a theorem of global convergence. A sequential halving screen exposed an important correction to the earlier interpretation. Ordinary raw and gravity paths already accepted $1/512$; the previous sparse grid had omitted it. The near-acceptance policy instead accepted $1/256$, a twofold nominal increase. Without eligibility deferral, the sole solve was spent at an unsuccessful $1/32$ and the final state was the baseline. Both successful frozen rescues used $\beta=1$, so eligibility, not damping, explained that particular improvement. In uncontended raw repeats, baseline search work cost 45.76 seconds for 0.116541 percent decrease; near-acceptance correction cost 74.90 seconds for 0.253536 percent decrease. The fractional decrease per measured operation-second was 1.329 times greater. Those timings excluded ordinary outer solve, commit refresh, initialization, and physical replay; they were not Newton speedups. A clock-anomalous original gravity/full run was retained and excluded, then repeated with independent UTC, monotonic, and child CPU measurements. \subsection{Matched six-update live test} The live pair kept the seed, mesh, $n=1.5,J=0$, absent central constraint, gravity-Schur inverse, restart 160, and $\eta=0.03$ fixed. Only the trial policy changed. Both first updates reached $1.614841549\,10^{-5}$ with the same recorded diagnostics. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{70mm}p{38mm}p{38mm}@{}} \hline Endpoint after six updates & Gravity curvature control & Coupled policy \\ \hline Final residual & $1.497197\,10^{-5}$ & $1.245830\,10^{-5}$ \\ Newton iteration seconds & 502.21 & 613.09 \\ Outer Krylov iterations & 354 & 341 \\ Auxiliary coupled iterations & 0 & 163 \\ $P(h)$ energy virial & $4.22590\,10^{-6}$ & $3.78554\,10^{-6}$ \\ $P(h)$ force virial & $2.71367\,10^{-6}$ & $2.31894\,10^{-6}$ \\ Minimum sampled density & $-7.73185\,10^{-4}$ & $-7.85522\,10^{-4}$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The new endpoint residual was 16.79 percent lower for 22.08 percent more Newton time. Excluding the common first update, residual decreases were 22.85 versus 7.29 percent, giving 2.53 times more decrease per iteration-second over that bounded interval. Both stopped at the six-update cap; neither converged. The new method initially crossed several modest residual thresholds later than the control before eventually overtaking it. Only one of three coupled searches was committed. At update two the full correction worsened merit but $\beta=1/2$ passed, with a very small 0.01795 percent residual decrease. Later ordinary steps benefited from the changed trajectory. Two other kept improvements remained unacceptable and were followed by ordinary backtracking; they were not accumulated into the model. This result supported retaining the policy as an experiment, not promoting it or treating every rescued step as an efficient update. Density-pressure virials remained undefined and local EOS extrema did not uniformly improve. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/COUPLED_TRIAL_CORRECTION_2026-09-18.md} and \nolinkurl{experiments/DAMPED_COUPLED_TRIAL_2026-09-18.md}. The latter covered 58 serial numerical/solver cases, 23 correction cases on two MPI ranks, 56 Python checker tests, twelve frozen cases including repeats, and the matched live pair. Its tests covered fallback, exceptions, budgets, rank-local rejection, preserved outer reports, and typed composition. \section{Shape freedom, field transport, and the displacement-order control} The next investigation targeted the weak coupled response itself, preserving the equations and avoiding an assumed gauge interpretation. At independent quadrature orders 10 and 14, scalar pullback changes were decomposed as \begin{equation} \delta f_{\mathrm{Eulerian}}=\delta\widehat f-\nabla f\cdot v, \end{equation} where $v$ was the generated physical displacement. Density and potential gradients were broken within-element gradients; facet jumps and RT transport were not included. Small Eulerian/pullback ratios therefore suggested transport compensation but could not certify a pure relabeling nullspace. At the old twelve-update $Q_3$ endpoint, these ratios were 0.05769 for density, 0.18870 for enthalpy, and 0.01288 for potential, versus seed values 0.3243, 0.3080, and 0.1993. A six-block sampled singular-response minimum fell from 0.0580574 at seed to 0.000143543 late, with largest sampled response near 22.1--22.6. The normalized block direction span itself changed with the state, so this was not a full-Jacobian spectrum or a rank proof. Despite an enthalpy energy virial of $4.06909\,10^{-6}$, the late nonrotating nodal surface radii spanned 0.997674--1.010093. Its direction was 99.9995107 percent cubic-invariant in sampled squared norm, while degree-eight spherical harmonics left 0.893679 of its nodal norm unexplained. This was fine angular structure consistent with mesh/discretization coupling, not evidence that all omitted modes were unphysical. The bulk and gravity discretizations also shared cubic symmetry. \subsection{The isolated $Q_4$ displacement experiment} The original $Q_3$ displacement could not exactly represent the order-four reference coordinate map: the affine identity control gave relative value error $9.01277\,10^{-5}$ and gradient error $1.23472\,10^{-3}$. On an isolated branch, only \nolinkurl{libmeanfield/interface/field/field_registry.cppm}, \texttt{Displacement::vectorOrder}, changed from $3+$ uniform increment to $4+$ uniform increment, with the increment fixed at zero. The rationale and date were recorded in source. The shared scalar surface collection therefore also changed from $Q_3$ to $Q_4$, increasing surface unknowns from 866 to 1538. Density/potential $Q_2$, enthalpy $Q_3$, RT2 gravity, geometry, and the radius-squared lift were retained. This was not a pure interpolation intervention: it added shape modes, changed surface normalization/preconditioning, increased derived pressure quadrature by one and gravity-force quadrature by two, and raised the geometry-inspection request from 18 to 24. Both variants started from analytic seeds; incompatible coefficient snapshots were not transferred. $Q_4$ reduced affine value and gradient errors to $2.11629\,10^{-16}$ and $3.24701\,10^{-15}$. Nevertheless, seed physical displacement direction norm grew 31.63-fold, from 0.00121967 to 0.0385749, and seed linear iterations grew from 26 to 67. Both initial linear gates passed, and small trial remainders remained quadratic. The fixed six-attempt live comparison was unfavorable: {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{70mm}p{38mm}p{38mm}@{}} \hline Measurement & $Q_3$ displacement/surface & $Q_4$ displacement/surface \\ \hline Root unknowns & 178,073 & 178,745 \\ Accepted updates & 6 & 3 \\ First three accepted-step seconds & 269.31 & 505.65 \\ Residual after three / own initial & 0.056755 & 0.906188 \\ All attempted Newton seconds & 547.34 & 638.42 \\ Krylov iterations, including failure & 354 & 492 \\ $P(h)$ energy virial & $4.22590\,10^{-6}$ & $8.89666\,10^{-5}$ \\ $P(h)$ force virial & $2.71367\,10^{-6}$ & $8.27467\,10^{-6}$ \\ Hydrostatic-gradient RMS & 0.0106811 & 0.325413 \\ Nodal radius span / nodal mean & 1.09849\% & 12.2559\% \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The fourth $Q_4$ solve and an independent cold endpoint solve both failed after 200 iterations at relative defect 0.0868564. Even its first three gate-passing corrections had already produced poor progress. The differing spaces and stopped endpoints prevented an equal-accuracy comparison; the result nevertheless ruled out matching displacement order alone as a sufficient cure in this configuration. The $Q_4$-only change was explicitly not recommended for promotion. It did not rule out compatible enrichment of multiple fields. \subsection{Two structural cautions} A naive replacement of mechanical shape rows by surface Bernoulli moments was identified as rank-deficient at an ideal $B=0,J=0$ root for the current trace spaces. On the actual closed surface, continuous $Q_p$ had $96p^2+2$ degrees of freedom, versus $96p^2$ for broken $Q_{p-1}$ potential traces. After enforcing the zero enthalpy trace, $Q_3$ surface supplied 866 rows against 864 DG $Q_2$ trace coefficients; $C$ added no independent constant trace dimension and the direct shape-measure derivative vanished with $B$. This was an objection to that proposed replacement, not proof of rank deficiency in the existing mechanical operator. Any alternative boundary formulation needed compatible spaces and a stability analysis. Second, correcting ambient interpolation did not make the radius-squared extension generate a physical dilation. If $b$ was the boundary trace of reference position $X$, the existing lift $E_0(b)$ differed from $X$; at a logical radius $1/8$ vertex it gave one eighth of the desired affine value. A proposed but unimplemented rank-one correction was \begin{equation} E(z)=E_0(z)+\bigl[X-E_0(b)\bigr]\ell(z),\qquad\ell(b)=1. \end{equation} It would give $E(b)=X$ while retaining the supplied trace and admit an exact transpose. This could place physical dilation in the mechanical test space, but would not automatically enforce the potential-energy virial, which uses the independent mixed potential. It was kept separate from surface-space reduction and was not claimed as an implemented remedy. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/SHAPE_FIELD_WEAK_RESPONSE_2026-09-18.md}. The $Q_4$ production change was isolated at commit \texttt{4be1a23c3ec2650af6a2a49528a8f5248cb001c3}; 22 targeted cases and 380,856 assertions passed. That correctness coverage did not convert its negative numerical outcome into a recommendation. \section{The bounded smooth-surface study} The user authorized a one-hour study, recorded as 19:30:15--20:30:15 UTC on 18 September. It retained $Q_3$ displacement, $Q_4$ reference geometry, $Q_2$ density/potential, $Q_3$ enthalpy, RT2 gravity, the same extension, $n=1.5,J=0$, and no central constraint. It changed only independent surface variation through a frozen affine embedding \begin{equation} q=q_0+Ba. \end{equation} The existing base $q_0$ was never projected. Real spherical harmonics through degree $L$ were evaluated at actual radial surface nodes and their interpolants orthonormalized in a quadrature-defined physical surface-area metric. All azimuthal components in that harmonic span were included. Correct primal and dual normalized maps were essential. For physical state scales $S$ and residual scales $R$, separate thin QR decompositions gave \begin{equation} SB=Q_xT_x,\qquad R^{-1}B=Q_fT_f, \end{equation} so that \begin{equation} Q_f^T(RF_{\mathrm{physical}})=T_f^{-T}B^TF_{\mathrm{physical}}. \end{equation} The reduced operator was $Q_f^T\widehat AQ_x$, not a blind transpose of a normalized state basis. Other fields and scalar equations remained active. The projected existing inverse was an approximation, not an exact reduced inverse. Both retained and original full residuals, and excluded shape force, were always exported. \subsection{Frozen late-state result} At the common six-update $Q_3$ endpoint, $\lVert F\rVert=1.4971971\,10^{-5}$, cold FGMRES used restart 160, cap 200, $\eta=0.03$, and one gravity-Schur sweep with relaxation 0.5. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{40mm}p{22mm}p{22mm}p{22mm}p{30mm}@{}} \hline Shape space & Parameters & Iterations & Solve seconds & Unit-trial full norm \\ \hline Full nodal trace & 866 & 61 & 32.184 & Pressure rejection \\ $L=2$ & 9 & 12 & 6.447 & $2.263903\,10^{-6}$ \\ $L=4$ & 25 & 21 & 11.249 & $2.432960\,10^{-6}$ \\ $L=8$ & 81 & 29 & 15.745 & $2.964119\,10^{-6}$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } All reduced directions passed their retained linear gates, with relative defects 0.01719, 0.01608, and 0.01409. Their original full linear defects were 0.15121, 0.16187, and 0.19207: none passed the original full Newton gate. Nevertheless, all four sampled trial alphas prepared and decreased both norms, and full residual decreases at unit step were 84.88, 83.75, and 80.20 percent. This was a real improvement in the original residual, obtained by restricting the shape equations, not a more accurate solution of the original Newton system. The $L=4$ root had 177,232 unknowns, only 841 fewer than the full root; its less than 0.5 percent dimension reduction did not explain a factor 2--5 drop in cold solve time by itself. Fewer Krylov iterations supplied most of the observed gain. Physical displacement norm fell from $3.96028\,10^{-3}$ for the full direction to $9.14977\,10^{-5}$ at $L=4$, 43.28-fold. The $L=2$ direction was nearly field-only, while admitting higher modes increased coupled displacement and curvature. After the $L=4$ unit trial, excluded shape force accounted for 98.38 percent of the remaining original squared norm. The inherited fine-scale geometry also remained, since $q_0$ had not been projected. Enthalpy-based energy and force virials improved to $8.11913\,10^{-7}$ and $6.41398\,10^{-7}$, but local EOS/hydrostatic errors were almost unchanged and minimum sampled density remained $-7.27628\,10^{-4}$. \subsection{Three cold reduced updates from the analytic seed} A conditional extension, recorded before launching, chained three saved unit candidates from the analytic seed. Each stage passed preparation, the retained independent linear gate, and both recorded norm-decrease screens. This was an externally replayed cold reduced-Newton chain, not a production warm-start trajectory or a fully converged model. {\small \begin{longtable}{@{}p{14mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}p{30mm}@{}} \hline Updates & Full norm & Retained norm & Excluded shape norm & Energy virial $P(h)$ \\ \hline 0 & $2.736592\,10^{-4}$ & $2.590732\,10^{-4}$ & $8.815010\,10^{-5}$ & $2.410694\,10^{-5}$ \\ 1 & $8.624827\,10^{-5}$ & $9.387845\,10^{-6}$ & $8.573583\,10^{-5}$ & $2.180785\,10^{-6}$ \\ 2 & $8.473526\,10^{-5}$ & $3.147803\,10^{-6}$ & $8.467677\,10^{-5}$ & $8.660498\,10^{-7}$ \\ 3 & $8.465191\,10^{-5}$ & $7.357283\,10^{-8}$ & $8.465188\,10^{-5}$ & $6.769653\,10^{-7}$ \\ \hline \end{longtable} } The retained norm fell about 3521-fold but the original norm only 3.23-fold. At the final trial, excluded shape force represented 99.999924 percent of the original squared norm. Cold solves took 18, 20, and 18 iterations and 10.574, 11.341, and 9.594 seconds. Full relative linear defects were 31.45, 98.18, and 99.90 percent; these were not full-system Newton solutions. The final force virial was $5.769064\,10^{-7}$ and mass error $3.79142\,10^{-9}$. Yet hydrostatic-gradient RMS rose from 0.001528098 at seed to 0.007255981, about 4.75-fold, while density remained negative at some samples. Nodal radius spread grew to 0.154699 percent, substantially less than unrestricted late distortion but not an exact spherical result. Small retained residual and excellent virial could therefore coexist with significant omitted mechanical force and imperfect interior fields. The result supported decoupling smooth independent surface parameters from the ambient displacement carrier, with nested configurable spaces and consistent dual restriction. It did not establish that a fixed degree-four space was sufficient at all rotation rates, that excluded force was irrelevant, or that the complete original mechanical system had converged. The subsequent native spherical-harmonic implementation and higher-index studies should be read as later developments, not retroactively attributed to this bounded experiment. All seven case audits passed 2,098 saved-artifact checks; a separate chain audit passed 107 checks with bitwise physical-state and residual handoffs. Actual builds, FEM cases, and expensive audits were serialized, and all seven FEM probes completed by 20:09:58 UTC. No production order, operator, or lift changed in this study. Optional $L=6$, rotating cases, higher indices, mesh/enrichment sweeps, and production integration were outside its scope. \paragraph{Evidence.} \nolinkurl{experiments/REDUCED_SURFACE_STUDY_2026-09-18.md}, producer commit \texttt{21cdbda22486e408adc52b65b25413f9380c7c30}, and the archived \nolinkurl{working/research/diagnostics/reduced_surface_2026-09-18} campaigns. Together with the failed $Q_4$ experiment, this was the main reason to prefer a controlled smooth surface span over indiscriminate addition of nodal surface freedom. \section{Native spherical-harmonic surface prescription} \label{sec:recent-harmonics} The reduced-surface experiments motivated making spherical harmonics a native, selectable surface prescription. The implementation on \nolinkurl{research/spherical-harmonic-surface-20260919} preserved the simultaneous Newton solve: surface coefficients, material fields, gravity fields and global multipliers remain coordinates of one coupled nonlinear system. This was not a separate surface-relaxation iteration. The preferred research candidate became maximum degree $L=4$ with all real azimuthal orders, hence 25 independent coefficients. The unrestricted nodal radial prescription remained available as a control. The choice of $L=4$ was an experimentally useful starting point, not a demonstrated resolution requirement for 50\% critical rotation. At reference boundary node $i$, with fixed radial direction $\widehat r_i$, the radial displacement is \[ q_i=\sum_{\ell=0}^{L}\sum_{m=-\min(\ell,M)}^{\min(\ell,M)} a_{\ell m}Y_{\ell m}(\widehat r_i). \] Omitting the optional azimuthal cutoff retains $M\ge L$. The real harmonics are normalized to unit squared integral over solid angle, include the Condon--Shortley phase, and use negative $m$ for sine and positive $m$ for cosine. The catalog is ordered by increasing $\ell$ and then signed $m$. Coefficients have dimensions of length. Zero coefficients preserve the reference mesh; $\ell=0$ is a genuine monopole rather than a removed gauge. \begingroup \small \setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}p{115mm}p{30mm}@{}} Configuration & Independent coefficients \\ \hline \endfirsthead Configuration & Independent coefficients \\ \hline \endhead $L=4$, all $m$ & 25 \\ $L=4$, $\lvert m\rvert\le2$ & 19 \\ $L=4$, $m=0$ & 5 \\ $L=8$, all $m$ & 81 \\ \end{longtable} \endgroup No odd-degree or nonaxisymmetric modes are silently excluded. Choosing $m=0$ constrains the shape about the fixed global $z$ axis; it does not impose axisymmetry on the three-dimensional interior fields. The reference center is configurable, but the frame does not move as another Newton unknown. \subsection{Architecture and normalization} The prescription implements the existing forward, transpose and pullback contracts, with a cached reference basis and zero derivative of that fixed pullback. It composes with the existing interior and fixed-infinity vacuum extensions. The numerical discretization now owns typed surface, interior and vacuum prescriptions, instead of the modern equilibrium compiler hardcoding a nodal surface. Existing two-argument discretization calls preserve their nodal behavior. The physics-facing EOS, pressure boundary, mass and angular-momentum specification is unchanged. Prescription/extension compatibility and coupled operator structure remain compile-time constrained. Requested degree, sampled rank and actual mesh resolution are runtime facts. Sampled aliasing is rejected rather than silently reducing the mode set. Modal normalization and the default material/surface inverse use a diagonal of the pulled-back reference vector trace mass matrix; state and residual factors retain their primal/dual relationship. Metric assembly checks FEM identity and a canonical trace-layout capability. The older nodal $H^1$ surface surrogate explicitly rejects harmonic coordinates. Geometry remained Q4 and displacement remained Q3. The harmonic samples feed the existing finite-element trace, so the resulting surface between nodes is not an exact analytic spherical-harmonic graph. Reference-mesh interpolation error remains. The native implementation also differs from the earlier frozen reduced-space experiment, which retained an arbitrary nodal base shape and used area whitening and QR maps. Physical residual and Jacobian equivalence is the appropriate comparison; identical normalized Krylov trajectories are not expected from those different coordinate metrics. The implementation was single-rank, consistent with the radial volume extension. Successful two-rank rejection tests do not establish distributed harmonic-solver support. \subsection{Native coupled results} Five live cases used the same mesh, cold Lane--Emden initialization, no central constraint, a six-update budget, restart 160, at most 200 linear iterations and a true relative linear gate $\eta=0.03$. Nonlinear convergence required $\lVert F\rVert/\lVert F_0\rVert\le10^{-8}$, with zero absolute tolerance. All 29 accepted updates were full steps, with one trial each and passing linear gates. \begingroup \small \setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}p{47mm}p{15mm}p{30mm}p{31mm}p{18mm}@{}} Case & Updates & Final $\lVert F\rVert$ & $\lVert F\rVert/\lVert F_0\rVert$ & Newton s \\ \hline \endfirsthead Case & Updates & Final $\lVert F\rVert$ & $\lVert F\rVert/\lVert F_0\rVert$ & Newton s \\ \hline \endhead $n=1,J=0$, all $m$ & 5 & $1.52715\,10^{-12}$ & $9.64952\,10^{-9}$ & 146.00 \\ $n=1.5,J=0$, all $m$ & 6 & $1.29965\,10^{-12}$ & $5.01751\,10^{-9}$ & 221.40 \\ $n=1,J=.01$, all $m$ & 6 & $3.86299\,10^{-13}$ & $4.29274\,10^{-10}$ & 197.23 \\ $n=1,J=.01$, $m=0$ & 6 & $3.08442\,10^{-13}$ & $3.42757\,10^{-10}$ & 164.90 \\ $n=1.5,J=0$, gravity-Schur & 6 & $2.19823\,10^{-11}$ & $8.48662\,10^{-8}$ & 189.54 \\ \end{longtable} \endgroup The first four cases converged by their stated criterion. The gravity-Schur case exhausted its budget, although its last update still reduced the residual by approximately a factor of 40; calling that endpoint a plateau would be incorrect. Process wall times, including setup and observations, were 210.55, 290.70, 265.89, 232.54 and 257.49 seconds, respectively. Timings are single-run observations on the workstation, not replicated benchmark statistics. At q18, absolute energy/force virial errors formed with $P(h)$ were $3.87036\,10^{-7}$ / $2.65938\,10^{-7}$ for the nonrotating $n=1$ case, $6.55153\,10^{-7}$ / $6.00565\,10^{-7}$ for $n=1.5$, and approximately $3.87\,10^{-7}$ / $2.66\,10^{-7}$ for both low-rotation $n=1$ cases. They also passed $10^{-5}$ at q14. The corresponding density-pressure virials passed for the sampled $n=1$ cases, but were undefined for $n=1.5$, whose independent density was negative at some integration points. The later sign-region investigation also detected a thin $n=1$ negative layer missed by ordinary volume quadrature. Global balance did not establish pointwise accuracy. For nonrotating $n=1.5$, the normalized EOS-density RMS was $1.25551\,10^{-4}$ and the hydrostatic-gradient RMS increased from $1.52810\,10^{-3}$ in the seed to $7.27475\,10^{-3}$ at the root, a factor of 4.76. This gradient diagnostic has acceleration units in the model normalization; it is not the normalized weak residual. The four converged cases had mass errors below $5.3\,10^{-14}$ and angular-momentum errors below $3.6\,10^{-16}$. The full nodal mechanical force remained almost entirely outside the harmonic span: Euclidean nodal-dual norms were approximately $9.22\,10^{-6}$ for $n=1,J=0$ and $8.99\,10^{-6}$ for $n=1.5,J=0$. In the latter case the retained modal force norm was only $3.61\,10^{-14}$. This is convergence of the selected Galerkin shape problem, not convergence of the former unrestricted nodal shape problem. The excluded dimensional Euclidean norm cannot be directly compared with a normalized nonlinear norm or the dimensionless virial tolerance. Nonaxisymmetric coefficients persisted in nominally spherical models. The $(\ell,m)=(4,4)$ coefficients were $8.97263\,10^{-5}$ for $n=1$ and $9.23867\,10^{-4}$ for $n=1.5$, compared with $a_{40}=1.09313\,10^{-3}$ in the latter. These are evidence to examine mesh/discretization imprint, not evidence of a physical nonaxisymmetric branch. Total Krylov counts were 212, 335, 296, 219 and 206 in the table's order. The $m=0$ rotating control used 26.0\% fewer Krylov iterations and 16.4\% less Newton time than the all-$m$ control, but changes the admissible shape and is not a pure preconditioner speedup. All $m$ remained the preferred three-dimensional candidate. Ten new harmonic tests and 64 selected existing regression cases passed; independent audits checked saved basis pullbacks, excluded force and physical/nodal equivalence. Those implementation checks do not validate the higher-rotation target. \section{Negative density: a located discrete representation defect} \label{sec:recent-negative} The subsequent investigation was observational: it changed no equilibrium equation, field order, shape prescription, normalization, preconditioner or Newton policy, and solved no new equilibrium. It examined four frozen states: converged $n=1$ and $n=1.5$ nonrotating harmonic models, the original $n=1.5$ seed, and the $n=3$ nonrotating seed. Only the $n=3$ case had a central condition; it was not a converged $n=3$ model. \subsection{What the weak EOS equation determines} Density and enthalpy are independent unknowns. Baseline density is DGQ2 and enthalpy is continuous Q3. On a stellar element the closure is \[ R_i=\sum_q w_q\varphi_i(q)\left[\rho_h(q)-\rho_*(h_h(q))\right], \qquad \rho_*(h)=\left[\frac{h}{(n+1)K}\right]^n, \] with physical mapped weights. At zero closure residual, \[ M\boldsymbol\rho=\boldsymbol b(h),\quad M_{ij}=\sum_qw_q\varphi_i\varphi_j,\quad b_i=\sum_qw_q\varphi_i\rho_*(h_h). \] Thus the closure selects a quadrature-defined weighted $L^2$ projection, not pointwise EOS equality. Its unique polynomial can have negative regions even when the sampled EOS target is nonnegative. Independently assembled element mass matrices and Cholesky solutions reproduced the converged $n=1.5$ density coefficients within $1.40\,10^{-14}$ and the field within $2.25\,10^{-15}$ in physical $L^2$, while its negative density was of order $10^{-4}$. Independent/production closure-residual differences were approximately $1.2\,10^{-17}$ to $2.1\,10^{-17}$ across the four states. Raising projection quadrature to q26 changed coefficients by at most $2.36\,10^{-7}$ and did not remove the undershoot. These comparisons identify the defect at the measured discrete root; it is not explained by incomplete closure convergence or the small measured quadrature difference. The implemented dependency also corrects an earlier intuitive explanation: negative density does not directly generate the represented enthalpy. Pressure is evaluated from independently represented enthalpy; negative sampled enthalpy is rejected during preparation. All negative-density q18/q26 volume samples in this investigation had positive enthalpy. Some surface witnesses had exactly zero enthalpy. Density influences enthalpy indirectly through the coupled stellar equations. \subsection{Spatial location and root-based integration} All 96 surface-adjacent stellar cells contained measured negative regions; no negative intervals were found on the sampled lines through the other 736 stellar cells. All stored density nodal values nevertheless remained positive. The nodes are interior Gauss--Legendre points, and positivity of their values does not imply positivity between them. Ordinary quadrature can miss thin sign regions: q18 and q26 missed the $n=1$ volume layer, while its sampled boundary trace was negative. For the same unchanged $n=1.5$ field, negative-mass estimates changed from $2.89\,10^{-5}$ at q18 to $2.18\,10^{-5}$ at q26 and the apparent negative volume nearly halved. The investigation therefore isolated zero crossings of the polynomial along reference-cell lines and integrated negative intervals. Define $M=\int\rho_h\,dV$ and $M_-=-\int\min(\rho_h,0)\,dV$. The mass denominator below is $\lvert M\rvert$, not $\int\lvert \rho_h\rvert\,dV$. \begingroup \small \setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}p{41mm}p{32mm}p{30mm}p{42mm}@{}} Frozen state & $M_-/\lvert M\rvert$ & $V_-/V$ & Measured physical radius range \\ \hline \endfirsthead Frozen state & $M_-/\lvert M\rvert$ & $V_-/V$ & Measured physical radius range \\ \hline \endhead $n=1$ equilibrium & $6.09585\,10^{-8}$ & $0.0327346\%$ & $.999643$--$.999886$ \\ $n=1.5$ seed & $3.66771\,10^{-5}$ & $1.83795\%$ & $.993813$--$1.000019$ \\ $n=1.5$ equilibrium & $2.24535\,10^{-5}$ & $1.49252\%$ & $.994917$--$1.001222$ \\ $n=3$ seed & $2.88372\,10^{-5}$ & $12.0835\%$ & $.934409$--$.978469$ \\ \end{longtable} \endgroup Radii are in reference-radius units and are not distances from the local, slightly deformed surface. The first three cases have intervals reaching the surface; the $n=3$ seed has an interior pocket in the same outer cell layer. Its surface trace is positive. Minimum-density witnesses were approximately $-1.14756\,10^{-4}$, $-9.26332\,10^{-4}$, $-7.21171\,10^{-4}$ and $-8.54870\,10^{-5}$, respectively; the $n=3$ witness had enthalpy $0.0455581$. These are sampled witnesses, not certified global minima. Tangential rules with 8, 12 and 16 points per direction agreed on the negative integrals to roundoff in these cases. The finest two negative masses differed by at most $10^{-14}$ relative, and whole mass/volume agreed with separate observations within $1.77\,10^{-13}$ relative. Eight points integrated each root-partitioned interval. Analytic controls, decimal-arithmetic audits and state/coefficient hash checks support the measurements. They are not rigorous three-dimensional sign certificates: unsampled angular pockets or roots below reconstruction uncertainty remain possible. \subsection{Mechanism controls and their limits} The initial seed independently interpolates tabulated Lane--Emden density and enthalpy into their respective spaces. The converged closure instead projects the EOS image of represented enthalpy. Both operations can undershoot; neither Newton nor rotation is necessary. With inward surface-cell coordinate $t\in[0,1]$, a linear enthalpy gives target density proportional to $t^n$. Exact quadratic $L^2$ projections in a flat one-dimensional cell are \[ \Pi_2t^{3/2}=-\frac{2}{105}+\frac{16}{35}t+\frac47t^2, \qquad \Pi_2t^3=\frac1{20}-\frac35t+\frac32t^2. \] The fractional profile is negative for $0\le t<0.0396969$. The cubic profile has a negative pocket $0.1183500$. An extra central-density condition cannot repair incompatible mass/EOS inputs; artificial forcing could instead conceal the mismatch. The energy inequality and its Lane--Emden mass relation are documented in equations (1.14)--(1.15) and Theorem 3.1 of Cheng, Cheng and Lin, \emph{Expanding solutions near unstable Lane--Emden stars}; the rotation bound above is our consequence of that inequality and the virial identity. The numerical calibration is only approximately critical. Independent DOP853 Lane--Emden integrations using five tolerance/start/step controls found $M_{\rm LE}=.9999999918534539$ for recorded $K=.36393905995216302$, permitting only $\beta\lesssim2.71552\,10^{-9}$. The control spread in mass was $1.95\,10^{-14}$, a numerical sensitivity observation rather than a rigorous interval enclosure. This near-critical input cannot represent the intended moderate rotational support under the continuum assumptions. The discrete equations need not satisfy every assumption: independent $\rho/P(h)$, weak EOS closure, negative density, approximate gravity and central forcing all require separate scrutiny. The argument chooses a sensible target; it is not a density limiter or a proof that a discrete residual cannot vanish. A separate experiment reduced $K$ by 1\%, kept target $M=1$, prescribed $J=.035$ and omitted the central condition. Its necessary bound became $\beta\le.00500000269$. The seed's central density was multiplied by $.99^{3/2}$ to retain its reference radius, making its seed mass approximately $.99^{3/2}$ while target mass remained one. This is an explicitly off-constraint initial guess, not density rescaling during Newton. The seed Bernoulli scalar still used target mass; that mismatch remained in the initial residual. Nonzero prescribed $J$ already breaks the nonrotating homology, so an additional central condition was not added. At fixed $M,K$ an $n=3$ homology can change size and $J$ without specifying a new dimensionless shape/rotation fraction. Neither input $J$ nor an uncalibrated angular velocity should be called a fraction of critical rotation. \subsection{Matched live field-feedback result} Two cases shared $n=3$, $J=.035$, $K$ factor $.99$, no central condition, all-$m$ L4/Q2, the gravity-curvature trial path, $\eta=.03$, ten updates and absolute target $10^{-12}$. Their initial completed norm was $.101333855231$. Only the inverse differed. Both exhausted the budget. \begingroup \small \setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}p{73mm}p{35mm}p{37mm}@{}} Quantity & Gravity-Schur & Stellar LDU + gravity-Schur \\ \hline \endfirsthead Quantity & Gravity-Schur & Stellar LDU + gravity-Schur \\ \hline \endhead Final normalized residual & $1.64730591\,10^{-4}$ & $1.29842469\,10^{-5}$ \\ Newton seconds & 918.881 & 1052.972 \\ Linear seconds & 348.441 & 335.399 \\ Krylov iterations & 534 & 410 \\ Trial preparation seconds & 477.771 & 621.957 \\ Final accepted $\alpha$ & $1/16$ & $1/64$ \\ Energy virial, $P(h)$ & $7.18429\,10^{-5}$ & $1.81141\,10^{-5}$ \\ Force virial, $P(h)$ & $5.23757\,10^{-5}$ & $2.90028\,10^{-6}$ \\ Energy virial, $P(\rho)$ & $6.96335\,10^{-5}$ & $3.51558\,10^{-5}$ \\ Force virial, $P(\rho)$ & $5.01663\,10^{-5}$ & $1.41415\,10^{-5}$ \\ Absolute mass error & $5.45536\,10^{-5}$ & $3.37148\,10^{-6}$ \\ EOS RMS / density scale & $3.99773\,10^{-4}$ & $4.00529\,10^{-4}$ \\ Bernoulli RMS / enthalpy scale & $.00408345$ & $.00372207$ \\ Hydrostatic-gradient RMS & $.656446$ & $.588702$ \\ $T/\lvert W\rvert$ & $.00497575$ & $.00497421$ \\ Angular velocity, model units & $.401764$ & $.401388$ \\ \end{longtable} \endgroup LDU reached a 12.687-times lower residual after the same update count, at 14.593\% more Newton time. Linear time fell 3.743\%, while preparation rose 30.179\%. These are evolving trajectories, not a speedup to the same converged solution. All full linear gates passed, and every rejected trial failed sufficient decrease; neither trajectory had pressure or geometry rejection. q18 density samples were positive without repair, not a global positivity certificate. Thus forcing positivity is not supported as the immediate remedy for this measured live obstruction. The LDU trajectory reached $1.30261014\,10^{-5}$ after update seven with a full step; three subsequent $1/64$ steps improved it only .3213\%. Its final squared residual was 36.500\% Poisson, 34.432\% hydrostatic, 20.234\% surface and 6.742\% mass. Gravity-only ended 80.254\% hydrostatic and 10.967\% mass. Field feedback is a substantive improvement on this trial path but does not remove small-step stagnation. Its merit over raw-Newton policies has not been established by this pair, since both shared the gravity-curvature strategy. \section{Virial consistency: pressure and gravity must be distinguished} \label{sec:recent-virial} \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=.95\linewidth]{figures/n3_ldu_meridional.png} \caption{Physical meridional density and enthalpy slices of the final rotating $n=3$, $J=.035$, $K$-factor $.99$ LDU plus gravity-Schur endpoint. The image shows the actual surface deformation without magnification. The model remains unconverged and fails the overall virial milestone; only four display subdivisions were used for this image.} \label{fig:recent-n3-slice} \end{figure} The final rotating LDU model does not meet the overall $10^{-5}$ milestone. Only force virial formed with $P(h)$ passes. Its signed enthalpy virials are approximately \[ v_E^h=+1.811408\,10^{-5},\qquad v_F^h=-2.900278\,10^{-6}, \] where both use $\lvert W_E\rvert$ as denominator. Their difference, approximately $2.10144\,10^{-5}$, agrees with the separately measured gravity-energy consistency discrepancy. Replacing $P(h)$ by $P(\rho)$ shifts both signed virials by approximately $+1.70418\,10^{-5}$, yielding $+3.515584\,10^{-5}$ and $+1.414148\,10^{-5}$. At one fixed state, pressure changes both signed virials equally: \[ v_E^\rho-v_E^h=v_F^\rho-v_F^h =\frac{3(\Pi_\rho-\Pi_h)}{\lvert W_E\rvert},\qquad v_E-v_F=\frac{W_E-W_F}{\lvert W_E\rvert}. \] Consequently, even an arbitrary common pressure-only shift leaves at least one absolute virial at or above half their separation, approximately $1.05072\,10^{-5}$. Pressure adjustment alone cannot make both pass in this frozen state. This is a fixed-state arithmetic observation, not a bound on a newly solved or refined model. q14/q18 energy virials agreed to below $8\,10^{-14}$ in both rotating runs. Quadrature stability must not be mistaken for mesh accuracy. The gravity gap remained about $2\,10^{-5}$, while EOS RMS stayed near $4\,10^{-4}$ despite the large algebraic gain. Since neither state solves the discrete equations and neither mesh nor order was varied, these observations do not establish a spatial error floor or identify an exterior-only cause. \subsection{Pressure-moment identity and the density test space} For nonnegative $h,\rho$, set $\rho_*=[h/((n+1)K)]^n$ and $\delta\rho=\rho-\rho_*$. Convexity of $P(\rho)=K\rho^{1+1/n}$ gives \[ P(\rho)-P(h)=\frac hn\delta\rho+D_P(\rho,\rho_*),\qquad D_P\ge0, \] because $P'(\rho_*)=h/n$. For a represented density test $v=\sum_i c_i\varphi_i$ and the same mapped quadrature $Q$ used in closure, \[ Q\left[\frac hn\delta\rho\right] =\frac1nQ[(h-v)\delta\rho]+\frac1n\sum_i c_iR_i. \] Current DGQ2 tests do not generally contain Q3 enthalpy. The first term can therefore remain even at zero weak closure. Compatible DGQ3 tests would permit $v=h$ elementwise, canceling the linear moment at exact closure under that same quadrature. Density would remain an independent field. At finite residual the remaining term is $c_h^TR/n$, which is not directly measured by a normalized Newton norm without undoing residual scaling. The convex remainder persists, and is not uniformly quadratic near vacuum: for $n>1$, $P''(\rho)$ diverges as density approaches zero; at $\rho_*=0$, $D_P=K\rho^{1+1/n}$, with exponent $4/3$ for $n=3$. Separate diagnostic quadrature can also retain a difference after assembled moment cancellation. The identity is conditional on nonnegative fields where evaluated and is specific to a constant-$K$ polytrope; a general EOS uses its own thermodynamic derivatives. The contribution of each term has not yet been measured in the final models. This is a consistency hypothesis and a diagnostic to implement, not proof that raising order, clipping density or changing pressure will solve convergence. \section{Physical two-dimensional model slices} \label{sec:recent-slices} The added optional diagnostic exports physical $xz$ and $xy$ cuts, with $yz$ and offsets available, showing independent density and enthalpy and the actual material boundary. It changes no equations or field representation. The important geometric contract is a cut by a physical plane, not a reference plane deformed afterward. Each stellar hexahedron is subdivided in reference coordinates into a lattice and tetrahedra. Crossed edges solve the actual mapped plane equation using a safeguarded bracketed root calculation. Fields are evaluated at those reference coordinates on the owning element. Density traces are not averaged between DG elements; supplied connectivity prevents triangulation across vacuum. A plane coincident with an internal face uses the positive-normal-side trace. Boundary curves are separately evaluated from stellar/nonstellar faces, and the undeformed outline is independently cut by the same physical plane. The plotter uses equal physical axis scales, no deformation magnification, and signed field values without clipping, logarithms or EOS replacement. Scalar values are rasterized on a 512-by-512 grid before color mapping, avoiding color-interpolation artifacts under triangle refinement. Exterior pixels stay masked. Images distinguish solid deformed and optional dashed reference outlines and mark known unconverged endpoints. Straight triangles and boundary chords approximate the curved cut. Neighboring parent elements may choose different face diagonals; small gaps/overlaps can therefore occur on curved interfaces. A covered raster pixel uses the first supplied triangle, without cross-element averaging. Tangencies or multiple crossings between subdivision vertices can be missed. These limits are explicitly documented and prevent using the image as a pointwise positivity certificate or interpreting every seam as a physical feature. \subsection{Display-refinement measurements} Four unchanged-state replays compared four/eight subdivisions for final $n=2$ and rotating $n=1.5,J=.1$ states, in both planes. Source buffers remained bitwise unchanged, and both resolutions used common axes and color ranges. \begingroup \small \setlength{\tabcolsep}{3pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}p{40mm}p{24mm}p{28mm}p{28mm}p{25mm}@{}} Model/plane & Area change & $\int\rho\,dA$ change & $\int h\,dA$ change & Perimeter change \\ \hline \endfirsthead Model/plane & Area change & $\int\rho\,dA$ change & $\int h\,dA$ change & Perimeter change \\ \hline \endhead $n=2$, $xz$ & $.12333\%$ & $.07667\%$ & $.07036\%$ & $.03065\%$ \\ $n=2$, $xy$ & $.12333\%$ & $.07667\%$ & $.07036\%$ & $.03065\%$ \\ $n=1.5,J=.1$, $xz$ & $.12495\%$ & $.00319\%$ & $.08797\%$ & $.03165\%$ \\ $n=1.5,J=.1$, $xy$ & $.12395\%$ & $.01249\%$ & $.07838\%$ & $.03088\%$ \\ \end{longtable} \endgroup These are relative absolute changes of displayed straight-triangle measures, including overlaps; they are not curved-FEM integrals, three-dimensional mass, virial errors or a mesh convergence study. Sampled chord errors decreased about fourfold and axial extents agreed. The rotating meridional model was smoothly oblate, with equatorial extent approximately $\pm1.12084$ and polar extents $-.988807,+.988480$; the equatorial cut was approximately circular. Its sampled negative density minimum $-8.59\,10^{-4}$ was retained. The $n=2$ outline was nearly spherical at radius 1.0049. Only the latter met its recorded virial milestone, and both remained unconverged algebraically. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \includegraphics[width=.98\linewidth]{figures/n1p5_rotating_refinement.png} \caption{Same-state physical slice comparison for the unconverged rotating $n=1.5$ endpoint at four and eight display subdivisions. Axes and color ranges are shared. This checks the displayed geometry and fields; it is not a change of the FEM mesh, a three-dimensional integral check or evidence of equilibrium.} \label{fig:recent-display-refinement} \end{figure} Final $n=3$ meridional/equatorial plots show strong central concentration and modest oblateness. Those exports used four subdivisions only. The separate $n=2/n=1.5$ display study must not be described as refinement verification of the $n=3$ images. Visual plausibility supplies an additional diagnostic, not physical validation. \section{What to carry forward and what remains unresolved} \label{sec:recent-next} The recent work establishes a usable native harmonic prescription, diagnoses a specific independent-density projection defect, measures order effects without changing density's physical status, adds reproducible physical slices, and shows real frozen-linear and live-nonlinear gains. It does not establish a converged moderately rotating $n=3$ model, a calibrated 50\%-critical sequence, or the ultimate 99\%-critical ambition. No ESTER comparison was performed. Global virial balance at $10^{-5}$ remains a primary acceptance milestone, accompanied by internal EOS/hydrostatic checks; an attractive image or a small subset of residuals cannot replace it. The evidence supports the following staged continuation. \begin{enumerate} \item Retain gravity-Schur as the strongest measured frozen linear-cost comparator and stellar LDU plus gravity as the better live candidate in the tested rotating $n=3$ configuration. The latter is conditional on the shared gravity-curvature trial path. Compare complete time to a common convergence and physical target before selecting a production default. Do not promote the new coarse surface/scalar wrapper merely because it lowers iterations. \item Remeasure coupled direction differences in the unbordered compatible rotating family, including true defects, field/modal composition and finite trial remainders. The centrally constrained nonrotating weak-monopole evidence is a motivated hypothesis, not a transferred diagnosis. A coupled trust-region or regularized step with a physical displacement scale is a reasonable swappable experiment. Radius must remain free, and surface/interior remain simultaneous. \item Strengthen the material response in controlled stages if its frozen block defects warrant it. Existing material preconditioning already contains the exact prepared enthalpy-to-density derivative; it is incorrect to claim that cross derivative is missing. Exact local mapped DG density mass inversion is a narrow candidate (27 Q2 coefficients per hexahedron). A stronger stationary enthalpy mass inverse must respect H1 connectivity and replaced boundary rows. Only then consider a more costly EOS-aware material/gravity Schur approximation. Such algebraic eliminations belong inside the inverse and need not make density a derived nonlinear field. \item Measure pressure-moment and gravity-energy consistency separately. Export the linear pressure moment, convex remainder, quadrature differences and both signed virials on identical states. Resolve the gravity relation/source and energy/force discrepancy with interior accuracy as the goal; the exterior need only be accurate insofar as it supports correct interior fields. The current observations do not justify allocating effort solely to exterior resolution. \item Define a physically compatible $n=3$ sequence in mass/EOS/rotation and calibrate a dimensionless rotation measure and critical reference. Input $J$ alone is not that calibration. Keep central homology handling optional and separate from incompatible physical specifications. \item After useful convergence is obtained, perform mesh and harmonic-degree studies, measure excluded surface force in a meaningful norm, and compare local profiles with analytic/nonrotating controls and eventually ESTER. Density-order results remain available as consistency controls; positivity intervention and logarithmic refactoring are deferred per the user's direction. \end{enumerate} A closure-consistent seed and an affine-target closure correction are additional untested hypotheses, not completed remedies. At fixed admissible enthalpy and geometry, exact local density mass solves can populate independent density or correct its weak moments. Any trial correction must preserve the original Newton tangent and be freshly verified. If combined with gravity correction, density must be corrected first and gravity rebuilt against its original affine target afterward. That operation can change mass, inertia and mechanical balance, cannot repair unchanged inadmissible enthalpy, and must pass the full residual acceptance test. For fractional $1